Nick Blaine's fate in The Handmaid's Tale finale is still a point of debate - not to mention the creative shift of his character 

The Handmaid's Tale has always left its fans questioning, but the debates around Nick Blaine still haven't died down even after the show has wrapped up. After Season 6, fans continue to argue over whether Nick received the ending he truly deserved or if his fate was mishandled. Was it a meaningful conclusion or a frustrating sidestep?

Well, it's a mix of both, depending on who you actually ask. Nick's character in The Handmaid's Tale was never easy to draw and portray, and that's exactly why his ending sparked such intense debates among fans.

Disclaimer: This article contains the author's opinion.

The conflicting layers that made Nick in The Handmaid's Tale so hard to read

Throughout the show, Nick in The Handmaid's Tale always operated on a blurry moral borderline. Fans initially saw him as Waterford's quiet driver, but his character gradually became more complex and vital. He wasn't just June's lover or Nichole's father.

His story involved climbing Gilead's ranks from a lowly Eye to a Commander, all while giving the impression that he was working both for and against the system. At times, his loyalty appeared to be with June and her safety.

At others, his silence and calculated choices hinted at something more self-serving.

By Season 6, Nick was firmly at the center of a debate about resistance versus loyalty. In one of the final episodes, he steps onto a plane bound to be blown up - a scene so intense that it divided the entire fandom into two groups. Was it an act of heroism? Or a man surrendering to a role he had fought internally against for years?

His journey was never straightforward. As fans learned more about his past, his childhood, his isolation before Gilead, and his ultimate choices to stay despite offers to escape, it became clear he wasn't simply a rebel or a loyalist.

He was both, which made his choices difficult to interpret and harder to accept.

Behind the scenes: How changes in leadership reshaped Nick’s arc

While The Handmaid's Tale maintained a strong narrative for five seasons, things noticeably shifted in Season 6. With Bruce Miller stepping aside to focus on The Testaments, a new creative team took over, and that change was evident.

Nick, who had been carefully crafted as a morally complex character, suddenly felt rewritten. His relationship with Rose, his quiet defiance, and even his emotional depth seemed to disappear. Longtime fans pointed out that his actions in the final season contradicted years of development. Why would a man who once smuggled resistance documents risk everything to appear loyal?

What made this shift even more apparent was how other characters were treated. While characters like Serena and Naomi received layered, redemptive arcs, Nick's role seemed compressed into a one-dimensional portrayal. Scenes that previously showed his internal struggles, quiet courage, and nuanced decisions were replaced with actions that didn't reflect his character's foundation.

This uneven treatment wasn't just a narrative stumble; it also changed the way fans perceived him.

The book vs. show divide: What could have been for Nick in The Handmaid's Tale

Part of the disappointment regarding Nick in The Handmaid's Tale stems from the expectations fans had for Margaret Atwood's sequel novel, The Testaments. In that book, there is strong evidence suggesting that Nick survived and continued fighting Gilead from within, operating undercover as a dedicated resistance member.

That version of Nick—one who stayed not out of loyalty but to quietly dismantle the system—felt more consistent with the early seasons of the show.

However, the Hulu show took a much darker turn. Instead of giving Nick a prolonged rebellion, his story ended with him boarding a doomed plane.

To many viewers, it seemed like the show preferred a shocking ending over a realistic one. Actor Max Minghella even told ELLE magazine that he enjoyed the more soap-like, dramatic twists, saying;

"I really enjoy the show when it leans into the melodrama."

Still, that choice came with a price: it ignored the years of careful storytelling that made Nick such a compelling figure.

Nick's fate is undoubtedly one of the most debated twists the show has ever faced. Fans weren't just reacting to a death; they were responding to a more profound narrative shift that felt sudden and possibly even unearned.

Whether you saw him as a rebel or a conflicted man, the way Nick was written off in The Handmaid's Tale still stings and hurts. It's not just about one character—it's about how storytelling respects complexity and whether long-established arcs should be sacrificed for spectacle.

In Nick's case, many believe the show opted for the latter approach, and the debate isn't ending anytime soon.

Trending

Stay tuned to Soapcentral for additional news and updates on TV shows, movies, daily soaps, pop culture, and more.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback