Nine Perfect Strangers Season 2 Episode 3 Recap: The guru’s inner demons are getting louder

If you thought things were weird before, Episode 3 of Nine Perfect Strangers Season 2 turns up the drama big time. With secrets spilling over, people falling apart, and therapy sessions going way off course, this episode, aired May 27, 2025, has everything: confessions, ice baths, paranoia, and power struggles.

Ready to dive in? Let’s break it down.

Right from the start, we feel the simmering tension between Martin and Masha. Martin clearly thinks Masha isn’t fit to lead the retreat anymore. He has lost his trust in her, while Helena is doing her best to back her up.

But Helena isn’t doing so great either. She ends up coughing badly and hides in the bathroom. Is she sick? Is that why she’s supporting Masha, hoping for a cure?

---

Agnes is falling apart in Nine Perfect Strangers

Masha finds Agnes asleep on the floor in Nine Perfect Strangers. Emotionally, she’s in a dark place. She’s carrying deep guilt from a traumatic past, the death of a baby. Although she won’t talk about it yet, her pain is clear as the sky on a sunny day.

Meanwhile, David is being kept away from the group. Supposedly, it’s part of the retreat’s rules. But something feels off. Why isolate him? What’s really going on?

Martin decides to take the rest of the group into the city, which nobody expects. They visit a remote museum, and that’s where things get even stranger in Nine Perfect Strangers.

Inside the museum, Martin administers the group's first dose of the retreat's mysterious medication. That’s when reality begins to blur for everyone.

Agnes begins to panic almost immediately. She hallucinates hearing church bells, feels overwhelmed, and escapes into a confessional booth. There, she pleads for answers and forgiveness. Flashbacks reveal her mother died giving birth, for which Agnes still blames herself. She’s haunted by that moment, and evidently, this is one of the things that is tearing her apart in Nine Perfect Strangers.

---

Victoria’s paranoid cafe trip

Elsewhere, Victoria's own trip into the town turns nightmarish. She visits a café and suddenly realizes that she can’t lift her hand. Panic takes over. She starts to believe everyone is staring at her. Is it the meds? Or something deeper?

Back at the museum, things get wilder. Peter and Imogen start acting out scenes from a sitcom. Brian begins dressing up. Everyone becomes trapped in their own little world. Is this therapy or chaos?

Eventually, the episode shows Martin noticing that Agnes is missing. He rushes to find her and locates her inside the confessional booth. They sit, talk, and finally connect. Martin admits he was wrong to rush the meds without Masha. Agnes opens up about her guilt and need for healing, making it one of the episode’s most honest and heart-touching moments.

Back at the hotel, Peter and Imogen return to their room and find David unconscious in the bed. Weird, right?

There’s tension in the air when David wakes up. Something happened between him and Peter in the past, and the show gives us just enough hints to get curious.

Masha pulls David aside for a new “therapy.” And this time it is all about walking barefoot in the snow and then jumping into freezing water.

David tries to be tough, but ends up collapsing from the cold. Later, Masha moves him to a guest’s room. This begs the question: Is she really trying to help him? Or is she just testing him for her own goals?

We find out Masha is using a signal jammer to block phone connections. That means nobody can contact the outside world, unless she allows it. Now, that’s a major red flag. She says it’s for the retreat’s benefit, but it feels more like manipulation.

As the episode ends, Martin and Masha have another heated moment. He’s tired of cleaning up her mess. But David, despite everything, still seems tied to her emotionally.

Turns out, they’ve known each other for 20 years. Their connection is full of dark history and unresolved issues. Things are definitely not over between them.

Episode 3 of Nine Perfect Strangers Season 2 is a rollercoaster of feelings. Everyone is dealing with inner demons, past traumas, and therapy that seems more dangerous than healing. Masha’s control is scary. Agnes’ guilt is heartbreaking. And David? He’s still a mystery.

What’s real healing, and what’s just a mind game? This show keeps us guessing.

All the latest episodes of Nine Perfect Strangers are now available to stream on Hulu and Disney+.

---

For more updates, keep reading Soap Central