"Not by design an evil creature" - Alien: Earth Episode 6's disturbing death addressed by Noah Hawley

Alien: Earth ( Image via YouTube / FX Networks )
Alien: Earth ( Image via YouTube / FX Networks )

Alien: Earth Episode 6, "The Fly," provided the series's worst and scariest moment, where horror was created not by brutality but by an accident! The show took its audience by surprise with Tootles (Isaac), a hybrid kid, and left the creator of the series, Noah Hawley, to justify why the scene was "not by design an evil creature." Instead, the eerie scene was to emphasize the randomness of peril and vulnerability of so-called immortal hybrids.

According to Decider, Hawley explains that,

"I sat down and I wrote what is probably the most disturbing scene that people will see on on television this year, you know, with the sheep, I had the sheep, that is not by design an evil creature, right? And there’s comedy to that, right?"

He added,

"That it’s like an evil sheep. You know, goats, we get. Goats have a satanic history. This idea that the sheep, who are not known for their intellect, was a sort of mastermind was kind of irresistible to me.”

This episode has turned into an Alien: Earth viewers' talk whirlpool because it recontextualizes the way the experiments and creatures of the series are perceived.

Hawley's explanation adds depth to the death not being sinister in nature, but questioning the consequences of Prodigy's meddling with nature.


The background of Alien: Earth Episode 6: "The Fly"

youtube-cover

Episode 6 of Alien: Earth, which was written by Noah Hawley and Lisa Long and directed by Ugla Hauksdóttir, aired on September 9, 2025, and introduces the hybrid boy character named one of the Lost Boys, referred to as Tootles. Tootles is at a critical juncture when he is doing a routine task. His work is simple: eating alien samples on Prodigy's command.

Yet, what begins as duty turns into disaster when an insect and the Eye-Midge, disguised as a sheep, set in motion events that prove fatal. The gesture is significant in that it does not depict the alien as uncaring. Instead, the hybrid dies by circumstance, a confluence of human curiosity, bodily necessity, and the hazardous unknown that defines Alien: Earth.

That is important in that the franchise is not simply displaying monsters in a gore manner, but delves into the bleeding edge between accident and intention.


Tootles' death and its immediate consequences

Isaac, or Tootles, is attacked after the Eye monster emerges and hauls him in a gruesome and nightmarish sequence. The boy's agony is brief but extremely unsettling, showing just how vulnerable hybrids actually are. To the Lost Boys, it is an unfortunate loss, and to the audience, it is proof that the Prodigy-woven fiction of hybrid invulnerability is a fatal myth.

Kit Young, who portrays Isaac, assisted further in a subsequent interview, stating that the scene was also significant in suggesting the hybrids are not immortal. According to ScreenRant, he said,

"It will have an effect on him, because also it's a surprise. Isaac's death is proof that this thing is a lie, that these hybrids can go, and now everyone's in peril. You're going to worry about Wendy and the rest much, much more, because they are going to be in real peril at all times. So, it's a discovery thing."

His words confirm how Alien: Earth Episode 6 brings the story back to where it belongs: it substitutes the myth of immortality with the fact that death can never be evaded, even when the human form has been genetically developed by humans.

The murder is not evil but a revelation, and that is what makes it much more frightening than an evil deed.


Noah Hawley on "Not by design an evil creature"

youtube-cover

After the episode was broadcast, Noah Hawley explained the terrifying images not to be of an alien monster as necessarily evil. Instead, the design of these new creatures, including the Eye-Midge sheep, was meant to evoke horror rooted in revulsion, not cruelty. Alien: Earth presents a threat through biology, nature, and human incursion, but not malevolent intent.

Hawley explained that his cast eagerly wished they could discomfort the audience as much as they did the first time they watched Ridley Scott's Alien in 1979. Horror then was one of sheer surprise on behalf of the xenomorph. Designs in Alien: Earth will rekindle that fear, but this time with the twist of mortality being accidental and inescapable.

This way, the show does introduce an aspect of reality: nature itself is not wicked, but its operation can be deadly.


Impacts on the Lost Boys and Prodigy

The death of Tootles is more than an initial shock. It is a callous reminder for the Lost Boys, who had taken Prodigy's guarantees of security and immortality at phase value. Their world is shattered, and their trust in the program is irrevocably shaken. On a literary level, it makes Alien: Earth a story of not only alien horror but of broken promises and human exploitation.

Prodigy's honor is called into question in the series as well. The company's use of the hybrids as guinea pigs and its claims of immortality are revealed to be lies. The death makes the actual-world danger of tampering with forces they cannot control evident. This plot twist maintains that Alien: Earth is focused as much on human accountability as it is on extraterrestrial horror.


Implications for the series beyond this book

Episode 6's storyline revises the Alien: Earth dynamics for the better. To start, they make hybrids vulnerable and their fate uncertain. Secondly, they raise the stakes for the Lost Boys and Wendy, who remain behind, and now have to live in terror and with uncertainty. Thirdly, the episode forces us to reframe the kind of alien creatures they are differently, not symbolically archetypal monsters, but survival and instinct-driven animals.

By removing the aspect of ill intent, Alien: Earth shows a gentler take on horror. It discovers that most terrifying moments are not born of ill intentions but of mistakes that no one could have possibly anticipated. Tootles' death is the turning point and confirms this truth with tear-jerking honesty.


Therefore, Alien: Earth Episode 6, "The Fly," contains one of the series' most disturbing murders. Through the use of body horror, narrative importance, and breaking Prodigy's myth of invincibility, the episode disapproves of the danger of tampering with life itself.

This moment in Alien: Earth serves as a reminder to the audience that although something may be frightening due to intent, at times it is frightening due to the unknown nature of life. The killing is tragic, sadistic, and symbolically laden, yet above all, it serves to remind us of how thin the line is between human aspiration and the brutalist requirements of living.

Also read: Alien: Earth episode 6 review — The Fly — Hybrid debates, corrosive beasts, and a question of free will

Edited by Anjali Singh