“Not going to be picky” Whitney discusses selecting a sperm donor on My Big Fat Fabulous Life 

My Big Fat Fabulous Life season 13 premiered on TLC on July 1, 2025, showcasing Whitney Way Thore's journey toward motherhood. The reality star began her search for a sperm donor during the opening episode. People Magazine exclusively published clips on June 30, revealing Whitney's approach to donor selection.

She sat with friends browsing through sperm databases while discussing her preferences. When one friend rejected red-haired donors, Whitney took a different stance:

"Look, I'm not going to be picky. Red's fine," she stated during the scene.

Whitney's life experiences as a plus-size woman managing relationships and personal objectives are chronicled in the TLC series My Big Fat Fabulous Life. A new chapter in her life has begun with her choice to try artificial insemination. The show chronicles her dating, weight issues, and her professional dancing career. The long-running series gains new material from Whitney's path to single parenthood.

Comparing the donation selection procedure to dating apps, Whitney said she felt overpowered by it. My Big Fat Fabulous Life focused more on her wish for a healthy child than on certain physical characteristics. Viewers who must make comparable reproductive decisions can relate to her experience.

---

What are My Big Fat Fabulous Life’s Whitney’s donor preferences and process insights?

Whitney approached sperm donation with straightforward requirements focused on health over appearance. She emphasized wanting a donor free from genetic diseases above all other considerations. Her practical mindset contrasted with friends who had specific physical preferences:

"My criteria for a donor, I feel like, is pretty straightforward and simple. I absolutely do not care what color this child is, what color the eyes are, the hair is. Obviously I want the person to be healthy with no genetic diseases," Whitney explained to cameras.

She maintained this philosophy throughout the selection process. Her friends listed various traits they would avoid in potential donors. Whitney consistently chose inclusivity over exclusivity when reviewing profiles.

Her approach reflected personal growth and maturity regarding parenthood priorities. Physical characteristics mattered less than ensuring her future child's well-being. The health-first mentality guided every decision she made.

Despite claiming flexibility about most traits, Whitney expressed one specific physical requirement. She wanted donors measuring 5'7" or taller to compensate for her own height. At 5'2", she worried about passing on challenges related to being short.

Whitney admitted to all the stresses of being so short. This personal experience influenced her donor selection process significantly. She hoped to give her child advantages she never had.

The height preference revealed deeper concerns about the societal treatment of shorter individuals. Whitney's honesty about facing difficulties resonated with viewers sharing similar experiences, and her practical approach balanced personal concerns with realistic expectations.

Whitney's friends supported her reasoning without questioning the decision. The group understood how physical traits could impact a child's future experiences. Whitney's transparency created meaningful discussions about parenting considerations.

Browsing sperm donor profiles proved more challenging than Whitney anticipated. She described feeling overwhelmed by the responsibility of choosing her child's biological father. The process reminded her of dating applications with higher stakes:

"And so more than the physical, I really want to know, do they have a high IQ? You know, is this the brain of somebody I would pick in the wild?" she wondered during filming.

Whitney questioned donors' intelligence levels and educational backgrounds. She worried about making decisions based on limited information available online. The weight of choosing correctly consumed her thoughts throughout this episode of My Big Fat Fabulous Life.

Her concerns extended beyond basic qualifications to personality traits impossible to measure. Questions about reading habits and intellectual curiosity plagued her decision-making process. The responsibility felt heavier than any previous life choice.

---

Whitney’s road to motherhood and all it entails

Whitney's desire for children crystallized after hearing a British friend describe motherhood. The friend called her child the "love of her life," inspiring Whitney's maternal instincts. This moment marked her decision to pursue pregnancy through artificial insemination.

Traditional dating and relationships held less appeal for achieving her parenting goals. She preferred controlling the process through medical intervention rather than waiting for romantic partnerships. The artificial insemination route offered independence and timeline control.

Whitney's choice reflected modern approaches to family building for single women, and her openness about the process helps normalize alternative paths to parenthood. This decision represents personal empowerment rather than settling for circumstances.

The donor selection process left Whitney feeling discouraged but determined to continue. She acknowledged never experiencing such overwhelming decision-making pressure before. The stakes of choosing correctly weighed heavily on her mind throughout filming.

Despite challenges, Whitney maintained optimism about her motherhood journey. Her realistic approach to donor selection balanced practical needs with emotional desires as seen on My Big Fat Fabulous Life. This process highlighted both excitement and anxiety about becoming a parent.

Season 13 of My Big Fat Fabulous Life promises to follow Whitney's complete journey from selection through pregnancy attempts. Viewers will witness her navigate medical appointments and emotional challenges ahead. Her story continues inspiring others considering similar reproductive choices on My Big Fat Fabulous Life.

---

My Big Fat Fabulous Life Season 13 premieres Tuesday, July 1, at 9 p.m. ET/PT on TLC.