One kiss, two broken hearts? Nic gets messy in Love Island USA love triangle

The latest villa drama on Love Island USA revolves around Nic Vansteenberghe, as he finds himself stuck between Belle‑A Walker and newcomer Cierra Ortega. In Episode 4, which aired June 6 in Fiji, a baseball‑themed challenge triggered a string of emotional fallout.

First, Nic and Belle‑A shared a connection during the challenge on Love Island USA. Then, shortly after, Nic and Cierra locked lips in the photobooth. The result? Belle‑A walked away emotionally confused, fan reactions on social media skyrocketed, and Nic became the season’s epicenter of tension.

---

Love Island USA recap: baseball match triggers messy triangle

Episode 4 of Love Island USA featured a mud‑soaked baseball challenge where Belle‑A and Nic shared a kiss near home plate, a moment that sparked fireworks between them. But soon after, Cierra, fresh into the mix, made her move in a secluded photobooth sesh with Nic.

Belle‑A confessed feeling conflicted after Nic seemed torn between the two women. On the villa’s lounge couch, Belle‑A described Nic’s mood as baffling. Cierra, meanwhile, reacted haltingly, satisfied to have scored a connection, and looking forward to more. One fan remarked online that Nic was playing out a Netflix‑style teen drama.

---

Villa vibes shift after the challenge

The Love Island USA villa mood shifted after Nic’s dual kisses. Nic tried to explain that the hideaway environment encouraged spontaneity and that he felt a strong pull toward both women. Belle‑A responded with anger, saying she felt disrespected and misled.

She emphasized that Nic’s actions made her feel foolish, though she still hoped to reconnect. Meanwhile, Cierra appeared emboldened by the kiss and saw the chemistry as worth exploring further. Love Island USA viewers noted that Nic’s position looked precarious: toss the dice for drama or risk losing both ties.

---

Nic and Belle‑A had a fairytale moment

Nic and Belle‑A shared a surprisingly tender moment during "Soul Ties." As they sat close, Nic told her,

“It would have been dope to be your first kiss.”

Belle‑A smiled and replied,

“I did. I did want it to be you..”

That was all the cue they needed; seconds later, they kissed. The moment felt genuine, a pause in the otherwise chaotic villa energy. But even in that sweetness, Belle‑A seemed to know what was coming. As they pulled away, she laughed and told him,

“You are trouble.”

It was the calm before the storm.

---

What this means for Nic

Nic is now walking a tightrope on Love Island USA. With Belle‑A being hurt and Cierra stepping up confidently, his next choice matters. Re‑coupling episodes are coming up too, where deliberate alignment matters more than spontaneous connection.

Choosing between Belle‑A’s emotional depth and Cierra’s bold interest will reveal whether Nic is chasing love or airtime. In the villa, loyalty is tested daily, but a misstep could cost him both women, along with viewer support.

---

A look ahead: Which path will Nic take?

As episodes keep airing, attention turns to Nic’s next actions. Will he choose the bond reignited with Belle‑A or chase the new momentum with Cierra? Both women bring contrasting energy to the scene.

The villa will likely respond to whichever words or gestures follow. Fans will also be watching how Nic’s decisions impact group dynamics. With Bella‑A’s pride wounded and Cierra’s confidence growing, either choice reshapes the villa’s social map.