Platonic Season 2 must address these 5 questions to justify the two-year-long wait

The Apple TV+ comedy is getting renewed as Platonic Season 2 first dropped in May 2023 and stood out for doing something sitcoms rarely attempt anymore, telling a story about friendship that doesn’t lead to romance. Rose Byrne and Seth Rogen play Sylvia and Will, two old college friends who reconnect in their 40s and immediately start messing with each other’s lives again.

Sylvia’s a mother of three trying to restart her career, while Will is recovering from a divorce and flailing at the bar he helped launch. The first season walked a fine line between chaos and chemistry, constantly pushing their dynamic without turning it into a love story.

Now, Platonic Season 2 is set to premiere in mid-2025, two years after the finale aired. Both Byrne and Rogen return, alongside Luke Macfarlane, Carla Gallo, Tre Hale, and Andrew Lopez.

With Will now living in San Diego and engaged, and Sylvia finally figuring out her career path, the show has a lot of ground to cover. But after all this time, season 2 will need to do more than just catch us up; it’ll need to give us a reason to care again, especially if nothing has really changed.

Platonic Season 2 must address these 5 questions to justify the two-year-long wait

1) Will Sylvia and Will ever actually address their emotional attachment?

Season 1 teased a closeness that went deeper than friendship, even if nothing romantic happened. Their fights, intense loyalty, and Charlie’s discomfort all pointed to something unresolved. But the show never let them talk about it directly.

Now that Will’s engaged and Sylvia’s moved forward, Season 2 needs to break that silence. Are they burying real feelings, or just clinging to something familiar? After such a long wait, it’s time to show emotional honesty. If the show keeps skirting this topic, their dynamic risks feeling stuck, like neither of them nor the show has grown.

2) How has Will’s move to San Diego actually changed him?

Will’s decision to leave the bar and take a corporate job looked like a big step forward. He’d been aimless, stubborn, and reactive throughout season 1, so that ending felt like real growth. But was it?

Season 2 needs to answer that. Has he actually changed how he handles stress and relationships? Or is he still the same guy who gets defensive and messes things up? Two years away should’ve matured him. If he’s still operating with the same habits, then that ending was just a surface-level change, and the character arc will feel incomplete and unearned.

3) Is Sylvia truly fulfilled with her new life and career?

Sylvia dove into event planning by accident, using Katie and Andy’s wedding as a way to stay busy and avoid her own stress. It gave her direction, but it never seemed like something she was passionate about.

Season 2 has to ask the tougher question: is she actually happy now? Has she found something that feels like hers, or is she still running on guilt and routine? Sylvia’s arc only works if her choices feel intentional. Otherwise, she’s just drifting from one identity to another, and that’s not satisfying for a character we’ve waited two years to revisit.

4) What does Charlie really think about Will now?

Charlie was never fully comfortable with Will’s presence in Sylvia’s life. Even when he tried to act calm, his uneasiness always showed through. The finale cooled that tension, but it never resolved anything.

Season 2 has to pick it up again. Does Charlie trust Sylvia more now, or is he just avoiding another fight? What would he say if Will moved back? This isn’t just about one guy’s insecurity; it’s about how honest these characters are with each other. If Charlie’s discomfort gets ignored again, he’ll feel like a placeholder instead of an actual part of Sylvia’s world.

5) What are the actual stakes of Sylvia and Will’s friendship now?

In Season 1, Sylvia and Will needed each other. They were stuck in life and pulled each other out of their ruts, even if it caused chaos. But now they’ve moved on, physically and emotionally.

Season 2 has to explain why they still matter to each other. Is there still something deeper keeping them connected, or are they just avoiding change? If their friendship doesn’t evolve into something new, it risks becoming nostalgic filler. After two years, the show needs to prove there’s still something essential in their bond — otherwise, the story just feels done.