Presumed Innocent Season 2 to feature Rachel Brosnahan in a lead role: Here's what we know

Apple TV+ confirmed on June 10, 2025, that Presumed Innocent will become an anthology series starting with Season 2. Instead of continuing Rusty Sabich’s story from season one, the show will feature a completely new case.

This change means viewers can watch the upcoming episodes without needing to see the first season. The move follows the strong response to the initial run, which became Apple TV+’s most-watched drama in 2024.

Also Read: The White Lotus finale cut a crucial love scene, and Walton Goggins wasn’t happy about it

---

Rachel Brosnahan joins as lead and executive producer of Presumed Innocent Season 2

Rachel Brosnahan, known for The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel and her upcoming role in Superman, will play the new lead and work behind the scenes as executive producer. She announced the news on social media on June 10, 2025.

In the series, Brosnahan takes on the role of Leila Reynolds, a defence lawyer handling a high-profile murder case for the first time. Her dual role suggests she will help shape both the story and tone of the season.

Also Read: I think the Love Island UK Season 12 producers jumped the gun by dropping the bombshell twist in episode 1

---

The story will come from a new novel by Jo Murray

Presumed Innocent Season 2 will adapt Dissection of a Murder, a forthcoming novel by Jo Murray. The book is expected to be released in mid-2026. Its plot centres on the killing of a respected judge and a defendant who insists on having a specific lawyer.

The series’ writers will draw on this material to craft an independent story that explores legal strategy and courtroom tension. No elements of Scott Turow’s original work will carry over to this season.

---

The core creative team remains in place

David E. Kelley and Erica Lipez return as co-showrunners, guiding scripts and overall vision. Executive producers of Presumed Innocent Season 2 include J.J. Abrams, Dustin Thomason, Rachel Rusch Rich, Matthew Tinker, Jake Gyllenhaal, and Rachel Brosnahan herself.

Bad Robot and David E. Kelley Productions continue their collaboration under Warner Bros. Television. This stable team aims to keep the series’ quality and style consistent, even as the story changes.

Also Read: How Young Sheldon helped revive the fan base for The Big Bang Theory

---

Production timeline points to late 2025 filming of Presumed Innocent Season 2

Reports indicate that filming is scheduled to begin in autumn 2025, with a planned mid-2026 release. These dates align with the novel’s publication schedule and provide enough time for post-production work.

While exact episode counts and release dates are not yet public, this timeline gives fans a rough window for when to expect new episodes. Further updates may appear once filming officially starts.

---

Viewers can look forward to fresh characters and settings

As the show is moving to an anthology format, all major roles and locations will be new. This approach lets each season stand on its own, with its own set of characters, conflicts, and legal issues.

Apple TV+ has not announced supporting cast members yet, but future releases will detail guest stars and recurring roles. This stand-alone format offers writers greater flexibility and creative freedom.

---

Presumed Innocent Season 2 will explore ethics and courtroom strategy

Early descriptions of Dissection of a Murder highlight themes of silence, trust, and evidence interpretation. Leila Reynolds must defend a client who refuses to speak during trial, testing her legal skills and moral compass.

Through her journey, viewers will see how personal beliefs and legal rules can collide in a high-stakes environment. The story promises a focus on procedure rather than sensationalism.

Also Read: The Many Deaths of Nora Dalmasso: Everything we know about Netflix's upcoming true crime docuseries

---

Anticipation grows for a new legal drama around Presumed Innocent Season 2

While trailers and episode titles remain forthcoming, interest is already high among legal-thriller fans. Brosnahan’s involvement adds a fresh face and voice to the series, alongside Kelley’s track record in courtroom storytelling. The anthology approach may draw in viewers who prefer complete stories contained within a single season.

---

Until more details emerge, viewers can catch up on the first season of Presumed Innocent on Apple TV+. Reading Jo Murray’s upcoming novel in 2026 will also offer deeper insight into the source material. Keep an eye on Apple’s announcements for casting news, teaser clips, and official release dates. Also Read: Ginny & Georgia gets honest about a real-life issue in Season 3