When Tomer Alpert stepped into the Shark Tank with Felt, an innovative app designed to revolutionize the way we send handwritten greeting cards, he seemed to have cracked the code for bringing personal touch into the digital age.
The app, which allowed users to create and send handwritten cards directly from their devices, caught the attention of "Mr. Wonderful" Kevin O'Leary, leading to an offer of $225,000 for a 10% stake in the company. At the time of its Shark Tank appearance, Alpert's company was valued at approximately $2.25 million and had already amassed over 60,000 downloads with an impressive 4.5-star rating on the App Store.
However, like many startup stories, the company's journey after Shark Tank took an unexpected turn, proving that even Mr. Wonderful's golden touch doesn't guarantee success in the competitive world of tech startups.
How did Felt do on Shark Tank?
During Season 7 of Shark Tank, Alpert confidently presented his vision for modernizing the greeting card industry. His initial ask of $200,000 for 6% equity demonstrated his belief in Felt's potential. The app's unique selling proposition was simple yet compelling: users could maintain the authenticity of handwritten cards while enjoying the convenience of digital technology.
The Sharks were particularly intrigued by the app's functionality, which allowed users to write messages using their fingers or a stylus, much like signing a digital receipt. Kevin O'Leary, seeing the potential in this blend of traditional sentiment and modern convenience, stepped up with a slightly modified offer that Alpert accepted.
Alpert's business model was built around various subscription tiers, catering to different user needs. The basic Felt Plus subscription started at $4.25 per month, while more feature-rich options like Felt PRO commanded $15 monthly. The app stored recipient addresses, enabled group card creation and handled all the printing and mailing logistics.
What set Felt apart was its attention to the personal touch - something increasingly rare in our digital world. Users could select from various card designs and write their messages as naturally as they would with pen and paper, but without the hassle of finding stamps or visiting the post office.
What went wrong for Felt?
Despite the promising start and O'Leary's backing, the app's story took a dramatic turn when the company announced its closure. While the specific reasons remain unclear, the shutdown serves as a reminder of the challenges faced by startups in the digital age. Even with a solid product, positive user reviews, and Shark Tank exposure, success is never guaranteed.
Felt's journey offers valuable insights for aspiring entrepreneurs, one of the key learnings being that Innovation alone doesn't guarantee success - even unique ideas need sustainable business models. Furthermore, it is important to note that the digital transformation of traditional products (like greeting cards) faces unique challenges in user adoption and market penetration. Shark Tank exposure and investment, while valuable, don't automatically ensure long-term viability, especially when extraneous factors such as these come into play.
While the app may not have achieved its ultimate goal of revolutionizing the greeting card industry, it demonstrated the ongoing desire to bridge the gap between digital convenience and personal touch. The company's attempt to modernize a traditional form of communication while maintaining its emotional value represents an important chapter in the evolution of social technology.
For future entrepreneurs, Alpert's story serves as both a cautionary tale and an inspiration - reminding us that while not every startup succeeds, each attempt to innovate pushes the boundaries of what's possible and contributes to the broader conversation about how technology can enhance human connection rather than replace it.
Trending
Felt announced its closure post-Shark Tank, despite Kevin O'Leary's backing.
Your perspective matters!
Start the conversation
