Stranger Things Season 5 finale’s Eleven sacrifice scene has a major plot hole, details explored

The Stranger Things Season 5 finale delivered plenty for fans to savor, from epic monster showdowns to deeply emotional, nostalgia-soaked moments, all culminating in an ending that has left audiences divided over what truly happened. But not all things were logical. A single scene, the very last sacrifice Eleven makes, confused the fans, as many noticed a significant plot hole.

It was quickly picked up on social media, where posts went viral as viewers expressed confusion over the logic behind El making her final stand. Many were also left debating what Mike Wheeler is actually claiming happened in the Stranger Things Season 5 finale.

Stranger Things Season 5 finale and the plot hole that comes with it

In the Stranger Things Season 5 finale, apparently, Eleven sacrifices herself to remain in the crumbling Upside Down so that Dr. Kay and others in the future are unable to use her blood to make more individuals with psychic powers. It is a touching scene, and it really seems to indicate that she is indeed dead.

However, things are complicated by the epilogue. Time jumps to 18 months later when Mike gives an optimistic hypothesis: Eleven did not die so badly, not a confirmed fact, though. He assumes that Kali had put an illusion of El dying to make the world stop pursuing her, but Eleven used hidden tunnels to escape.

And here is where the plot hole is introduced. Previously, the show clearly stated that the kryptonite tech blocks all psychic powers, and during El’s sacrifice, those were very clearly on. Assuming that is the case, she should not have been able to telepathically reach out to Mike at that time of need, but as we saw, she obviously did. The Stranger Things Season 5 finale goes a bit too far with the feeling of her death, then undoes the move with a clarification that is not exactly consistent with the regulations of the show itself.

Mike’s theory in the Stranger Things Season 5 finale

Mike Wheeler, the most romantic and optimistic one in the show, may also be an unreliable narrator. In the Stranger Things Season 5 finale’s fast-forward-style epilogue, he recounts an alternative reality of what happened, where Eleven did not die. According to him, Eleven could communicate with him despite her powers being jammed by sonic technology near the military base, because Kali was using her psychic powers to shield Eleven. He proposes that Kali created an illusion of El while she escaped through the tunnels.

What went wrong here? Firstly, Kali was way too far from the gate to use her powers, and second, even if she could, how would she know exactly when to use her powers and save Eleven? It also implies that the telepathy between El and Mike was a fake one, perhaps projected by Kali, for Eleven could not use her powers near the military gate with three kryptonite machines.

The series seems to consider this to be a possibility, but it is never confirmed. For a fan, this creates confusion. Do we believe him, or is it just Mike's way of dealing with Eleven's death and having his happy ending? While it makes perfect emotional sense, it doesn’t quite jibe from a logical perspective.

Fan reaction

People are reacting so strongly because Stranger Things has been huge for years, and fans analyze every tiny detail. So when the Stranger Things Season 5 finale gives Eleven an emotional but slightly confusing ending, it sparks intense debate.

It also matters because viewers are deeply invested in Eleven. She's the heart of the show. Fans feel like her ending should have been clearly tragic or clearly hopeful, not vague, and based on some kind of unclear idea. That's why some think the emotion worked, but the story logic didn't.

The Duffer Brothers have said the ambiguity in the Stranger Things Season 5 finale is intentional: life is not always clear-cut, and the stories of heroes often rely on faith. In that sense, the decision as to whether the ending is the truth or hope rests with the viewer, and for a show as messy and emotional as Stranger Things, there may be no better fit.

Trending

For more such insights on the Stranger Things Season 5 finale, keep following SoapCentral.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback