The Beast in Me Episode 2 recap: Aggie’s hunt for the truth pulls her deeper into Nile’s dark orbit

Episode 2 of The Beast in Me, called Just Don't Want to Be Lonely, dropped on Netflix in November 2025. The whole miniseries with eight episodes hit the platform at once on November 13.

Claire Danes and Matthew Rhys lead the cast, exploring the tangled, shadowy life of Nile Jarvis, a famous artist with a past he would rather keep buried. Episode 2 digs deeper into Nile’s world, heightening the pressure and throwing even more dangerous deals his way. The tension, all those questions about identity, and the messy psychology at the heart of the show really come through in this one.

The second episode of The Beast in Me takes Aggie as its main character. She is an accomplished writer and the new neighbor of Nile Jarvis, who is portrayed as having a conflicting world of his own.

At first, Aggie seems to be a very complicated individual. She is grieving for her son, who died in an accident, and has her writing career put on hold. Later on in the episode, she makes the decision to write a book about Nile Jarvis, a move that drags her deeper into his dark world.

---

The Beast in Me Episode 2 recap – Just Don’t Want to Be Lonely

The Beast in Me Episode 2 opens right after Teddy Fenig’s strange and sudden death. Reporters crowd the shoreline, snapping photos of his empty car, some clothes, and what looks like a suicide note, but there is no sign of Teddy himself.

Agatha, or Aggie as most people call her, forces herself to go down there, even though she hardly ever leaves the house. She ends up face-to-face with Teddy’s heartbroken mother, who does not doubt that her son wasn’t suicidal. Mrs. Fenig lets her anger spill over, blaming Aggie and accusing her of wanting this to happen.

The accusation rattles Aggie. She runs, shaken and stuck with the awful thought that, deep down, there is a bit of truth to it, as she did want something bad to happen to Teddy.

Meanwhile, Nile Jarvis heads out for a strangely peaceful jog in Oyster Bay and bumps into Aggie. He barely reacts to Teddy’s death, almost shrugs it off, calling it some sort of karmic payback. That throws Aggie off. Nile’s charm feels like a mask now, and the way he looks right through her, it’s hard not to wonder what he is really hiding. She is sure there is something dark beneath that polished surface.

In The Beast in Me Episode 2, Aggie is desperate for answers, so she calls Brian Abbott, the FBI agent who showed up at her place with a warning that he is now pretending never happened. When Abbott answers, he is actually in bed with Erika Breton, another agent, which just adds more mess to his life.

He tries to brush Aggie off, but she won’t let it go, so he finally agrees to meet her in Central Park. They end up under a bridge, where Aggie spills everything: her past with Teddy, her gut feeling about Nile, even that time she hurled a brick through Teddy’s office window. Abbott tries to calm her down, saying there is nothing really tying Nile to Teddy. But as soon as he is back at his desk, he can’t help himself, and he looks up Teddy’s name in the FBI system. Whether he wants to admit it or not, he is in.

The Beast in Me Episode 2 shows Aggie weaving her way through a crowd protesting Jarvis Yards, Nile’s big Manhattan project. Councilwoman Olivia Benitez is out front, blasting Nile in public. She says he already has “enough blood on his hands,” and you can just feel how Nile’s reputation still hangs over everything and threatens her opponents.

That’s exactly what lights a fire under Aggie. She sits in front of those blank manuscript pages, nothing coming. So she goes to see her editor, Carol, and just blurts it out: she hasn’t written a single word of her next book. But she knows what she wants to write: Nile Jarvis. The infamous tech mogul everyone whispers about, the guy accused of murdering his wife, who has never given anyone an interview.

Getting him to talk would be huge, but also dangerous. But you can sell danger. Carol hesitates, but she knows Aggie is right. The risk is what makes it worth chasing.

Aggie walks right up to Nile in The Beast in Me Episode 2 while he is halfway through a roasted chicken at his kitchen counter. She doesn’t waste time and tells him straight up that if he keeps quiet, everyone else gets to decide who he is. Protesters, politicians, and the media will all tell their own version. But talking to her is his shot at setting the record straight. Nile tries to brush it off at first, cracks a joke about people thinking he killed his wife, then immediately insists he didn’t.

Still, Aggie knows what matters to him. Legacy. Reputation. The story people remember. That gets his attention. He says he will think it over.

On the other hand, in The Beast in Me Episode 2, there is a whole other game unfolding behind the scenes. While Nina Jarvis, Nile’s new wife and, before that, his late wife’s assistant, takes Aggie out for a casual morning walk, Nile’s head of security, Rick, sneaks into Aggie’s house. He rifles through her bedroom and her office and finds a note with Abbott’s name on it.

Whatever worries Nile’s household has, one thing is obvious: they are keeping a much closer eye on Aggie than she ever guessed.

As they walk, Nina starts opening up about her past. She loved Madison Jarvis, she says, and swears that nothing happened between her and Nile until after Madison died. Madison was struggling, Nina admits, a fact the family kept quiet. Sure, Nile is tough, but Nina doesn’t see him as some kind of villain.

She comes across as honest, but the way she talks about Nile, the timing, the details she chooses to share– it all suggests there is more going on beneath the surface.

In The Beast in Me Episode 2, Nile says yes to the interviews. Aggie heads home, feeling good about the progress. Then, out of nowhere, a brick smashes through her window. Maybe Teddy’s friends did it, maybe not. Either way, the warning is clear: someone is paying attention.

Erika tells Abbott she is leaving her husband, but there’s not much romance between them, just tension. Afterward, outside the station, Rick confronts her. Turns out, Erika has been feeding him information the whole time. Nile’s reach goes way past what Aggie thinks. The walls are closing in, and now Abbott is caught up in it without even realizing it.

By the end of The Beast in Me Episode 2, Aggie throws herself into the riskiest story she has ever tackled. Nile lets her in, finally. The web of lies, secret watching, and shady alliances around the Jarvis house is starting to unravel. Teddy’s death dragged Aggie back into this world, sure, but it has also landed her in more danger than she even sees coming.

Episode 3 of The Beast in Me, called Elephant in the Room, digs into the family dynamics. We meet Nile’s dad, Martin Jarvis, and it’s immediately clear things aren’t right. Martin runs the house with an iron fist, even pushing his two young sons into physical fights, like he thinks violence makes them stronger.

Then there is Nile’s security guard, Wrecking Ball. Turns out, he is actually Nile’s uncle, Rick. And behind Nile’s back, Rick keeps Martin in the loop about Aggie’s book project, which everyone is starting to see as a real threat.