The Summer I Turned Pretty: Here’s all you need to know about Jeremiah’s favorite Mirror Glaze cake

The Summer I Turned Pretty ( Image via YouTube / Prime Video )
The Summer I Turned Pretty ( Image via YouTube / Prime Video )

In The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 3, Episode 5, that shocking moment with Jeremiah is already one of the most talked-about moments of the season for the refusal to let go of a certain, expensive wedding cake. Jeremiah's desire? A two-tier dark chocolate cake with raspberry coulis filling, topped with a shiny mirror glaze, costs $750.

The episode was shocking and something people were talking about, especially considering the strict budget of the wedding. This wedding cake scene in The Summer I Turned Pretty is an afterthought moment, but a small and important piece of character development. When Belly tries to save money, Jeremiah stands firm, telling her that the cake is his "one thing" when it comes to the wedding.

The scene not only deals with their different perspectives on money and priorities, but also keeps fueling fan debate within and beyond the series.


The particular cake Jeremiah wants

Jeremiah is quite firm that he will not change his mind once he has made up his mind about his cake. He says it is a two-layer dark chocolate cake with layers of raspberry coulis and topped with mirror glaze. When Belly makes her trip out to the bakery to finalize the order, she is informed that it will be $750, and this immediately sets off alarm bells as she starts to worry about how she would buy it.

But for Jeremiah, this cake is not a sweet treat to be enjoyed, but one that will place him at the center of his marriage dream. This is important in The Summer I Turned Pretty because it shows Jeremiah's detail orientation and his innate flair for style and taste as opposed to cost.

The mirror glaze, a trendy approach to modern patisserie that is renowned for its glassy appearance, is something he will not compromise on.


Why it's his "one thing"

Jeremiah's stance regarding the cake is the one thing in the episode that he will not compromise on, no matter what. Jeremiah tells Belly that this cake is the one thing that he would not exchange for anything. Belly, considering they have a budget, proposes that they have a plain milk chocolate cake that has one tier and raspberry coulis substituted instead, but Jeremiah refuses.

In The Summer I Turned Pretty, the situation is made into a dramatic but concise confrontation. Belly cites thrift, bringing to mind all the other costs they will have to bear for the wedding. Jeremiah responds that he will put the cake on a credit card and "pay it off later," underlining their value and precedence differences.


The mirror glaze factor

Mirror glaze is a cooking process that creates a shiny, reflective surface, usually one that is made from a mixture of sugar, chocolate, and gelatin. While it makes a gorgeous-looking cake, it also takes more time and money to prepare than ordinary frosting.

It wasn't an arbitrary choice to add a mirror glaze to The Summer I Turned Pretty; it speaks to Jeremiah's aesthetic sense and perhaps even an ideal for a flawless wedding photo. But within the story, it is symbolic of the irony of being functional and beautiful.


Episode 5 context

The cake scene appears in The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 3, Episode 5, which is noteworthy for shifting the viewpoint to Conrad's. In it, Jeremiah is shown balancing work and attempting to connect with his dad, and Belly must navigate the practical and emotional aspects of wedding planning.

The dessert fight is one of a number of scenes where practical decisions meet emotional tides. Jeremiah's refusal to be swayed by Belly's compromising attempts and his insistence that they spend $750 on the dessert is a microcosm for all of their dynamics within the relationship.


Why it worked for viewers

One of the reasons why this cake moment is so memorable is that The Summer I Turned Pretty tends to use small moments to shed light on larger character traits. Jeremiah's insistence on not giving up shows how strongly he believes in some ideas, while Belly's insistence shows how focused she is on duty.

The fact that a decision so apparently trivial, dark over milk chocolate, two layers or one, mirror glaze or none, is capable of causing major conflict is exactly the kind of reality fans have come to expect from the series.


Jeremiah's fixation on a two-layered dark chocolate cake and raspberry coulis mirror glaze is ridiculous at one glance, but in The Summer I Turned Pretty, it's a highly symbolic action. It's a debate about what's most important, what you can afford, and the mismatch between the worlds of dreams and the realities of what you can afford to pay for.

Whether or not they see it as a charming quirk or a reflection of poor priorities, the $750 cake is one of Season 3's most water-cooled specifics, and it's just because Jeremiah simply couldn't bear to part with that mirror glaze.

Also read: What are dirt bombs in The Summer I Turned Pretty? All about Belly’s favorite muffins

Edited by Sugnik Mondal