The Witcher Season 4 skipping this character might not work for the show

"The Witcher" Season 3 Premiere At The Outernet - Source: Getty
Anya Chalotra at "The Witcher" Season 3 Premiere At The Outernet (Image via Getty)

The Witcher Season 4 promises several changes, but omitting a significant character like Yennefer would be a serious misstep for the series. As one of the series' emotional core and narrative pillar, Yennefer of Vengerberg is crucial due to her deep involvement with the story of Geralt and Ciri.

According to the latest developments, while reports suggest that the leads are returning, there is fear about splitting up the trio—Geralt, Ciri, and Yennefer—in most of The Witcher Season 4. The decision follows a trend in the past seasons when the leads have diminishing screen time together, something critics and audiences alike have frowned upon.

The absence or reduced role of Yennefer in The Witcher Season 4 could weaken the show’s dynamic, especially as it adapts deeper layers of Andrzej Sapkowski’s novels, where Yennefer plays a vital role.

With the series making huge casting adjustments and plot changes, sidelining Yennefer's character or minimizing her involvement might not be in the best interest of the show, which could potentially risk disappointing loyal fans who appreciate the trio's relationship.


Yennefer’s role in The Witcher series

Yennefer of Vengerberg is more than a strong sorceress; she is an integral character within the universe of The Witcher. Holding a position of great importance within the book series right from the outset, Yennefer's on-again-off-again connection with Geralt has been pivotal to much of the narrative's emotional resonance.

Within the Netflix series, Anya Chalotra's performance as Yennefer has added considerable weight to the show, with Yennefer's storyline unfolding in tandem alongside Geralt and Ciri. Her guidance of Ciri and collaboration with Geralt form a surrogate filial dynamic which underpins the story.

As reported by several sources, had Yennefer been absent or marginalized, there would be a gap in the structure of the narrative since she is both a mentor and a moral compass for Ciri and a principal partner for Geralt.


The impact of separating the trio in The Witcher Season 4

The Witcher Season 4 is anticipated to follow the same pattern of isolating its three lead characters. In earlier seasons, this approach has been reproached for undercutting the potential camaraderie between Geralt, Yennefer, and Ciri. Insufficient shared screen space has made their connection appear superficial and rushed, particularly in comparison to the original material.

This design decision might have been partly because of the show's convoluted timelines and necessity to bring together several storylines. Nevertheless, with the recasting of Geralt (Liam Hemsworth taking over from Henry Cavill) and constant cast changes, the show has more to worry about in retaining its central dynamic.

The ongoing segregation of the leads during The Witcher Season 4 may compromise the emotional stakes and diminish the effects of pivotal storylines, especially if Yennefer's contribution is downgraded.


Audience expectations from The Witcher Season 4 and possible consequences

The Witcher fans have certain expectations of on-screen dynamics between Geralt, Yennefer, and Ciri. Yennefer's presence has been a huge selling point, and her absence or diminished role in The Witcher Season 4 might be a letdown for fans who have been following her story since the start.

Taking Yennefer out or sidelining her would probably be viewed as a missed opportunity, particularly as the show ventures into new ground with major cast changes and plot twists. The choice also has implications for whether the show can accurately transition the novels, where Yennefer's agency is central.

As the series gears up for its final two seasons, what they do with Yennefer's character will be closely followed by fans and might influence the overall reception of the show.


Slated to release later this year, The Witcher Season 4's decision to split up its leading characters, and possibly downplaying of Yennefer's role, follows a trend that has previously been criticized.

Edited by Ranjana Sarkar