"This guy is playing a game": Love Island USA fans call out Jeremiah over Huda drama

In a tense and emotional moment on Love Island USA, Huda Mustafa opened up about being a mom, and Jeremiah Brown’s reaction has fans raising eyebrows, waving red flags, and basically yelling at their TVs. It all went down when Huda, 24, pulled Jeremiah, 25, aside to have a serious heart-to-heart. What followed was a conversation that started with a promise but quickly took a nosedive, and now, fans of Love Island USA aren’t holding back.

From the get-go, viewers could tell something big was about to happen. Huda, a fitness influencer from North Carolina, told Jeremiah that she had waited until she really trusted him to be fully honest. But the second she said,

“I am a mom,”

his face said it all, no poker face in sight. He leaned back, let out a heavy sigh, and covered his eyes. Not exactly the response she was hoping for.

And fans noticed.

One viewer commented, summing up the growing suspicion that Jeremiah might not be as invested as he claims.

---

Jeremiah’s reaction has Love Island USA viewers concerned

When Huda finally revealed that she’s been a mom for four years, Jeremiah’s reaction didn’t exactly scream supportive. His eyes darted away, he sighed multiple times, and at one point, even covered his face with his hands.

“You’re a mom?! And you’re 24? How many kids?”

He asked, visibly rattled. When Huda replied that she had one child, his body language shifted again, this time more disappointed than surprised.

This reaction struck a nerve with fans.

One viewer wrote

“He leaving her lol.”

Another fan added

"Why are we giving these BOYS our power! Sis you’re a mom and that is INCREDIBLE! If he can’t “handle” it he doesn’t deserve you or your sweet babe! Don’t let him take that joy and love from you!"

For a moment, that was supposed to build trust. It left Love Island USA fans with serious doubts about where Jeremiah’s heart really is.

---

Huda handles it with grace, but fans fear it’s not enough

Despite Jeremiah’s stunned reaction, Huda remained calm and vulnerable. She even tried to keep the connection going, telling him,

“Look at me.”

But Jeremiah struggled to maintain eye contact and replied with,

“Hold on, I can’t!”

covering his face as if he were still processing the news.

To Huda’s credit, she didn’t backtrack or downplay anything. She led with honesty and openness. But Love Island USA fans aren’t sure Jeremiah is on the same page.

One person wrote,

With emotions running high and fans fiercely defending Huda’s transparency, the moment became a defining one not just for the couple but for how Love Island USA viewers perceive Jeremiah going forward.

---

Fans rally behind Huda in a big way

Whatever Jeremiah’s intentions on Love Island USA may be, the internet has made one thing clear: Huda has a whole support system backing her up. Her openness, especially in such a vulnerable moment, has earned her serious respect.

One fan gushed

"Huda a pretty crier."

The Love Island USA audience is no stranger to drama, but this moment hit deeper. It wasn’t about petty fights or who kissed whom; it was about real life, honesty, and the way people react to hearing something meaningful.

For many, it wasn’t just disappointing to see Jeremiah’s reaction. It was a reminder that even on a dating show, moments of truth like this matter.