Wayward turns into Netflix’s most talked-about and polarizing thriller, here's why

Wayward has quickly become one of Netflix's most controversial new thrillers. Its notoriety isn’t just due to dominating international charts, but because it blends mystery, psychological drama, and social commentary in ways that have sparked debate. The show's quirky tone, ambivalent critical reception, and its subversion of the troubled teen industry are the central reasons that it feels so polarizing.

At its core, it is no ordinary thriller. Created by Mae Martin, the Canadian series is set in the early 2000s in the fictional town of Tall Pines, Vermont, and follows two teenagers who are residents at a therapeutic boarding school. It's a setting deliberately disconnected from modern technology and social media, and that sets up a creepy, isolating vibe for the series.

And with that? A series that critics would find ambitious, but in which viewers seem more polarized.

The concept behind Wayward

Wayward is set at Tall Pines Academy, a therapeutic boarding school in which teenage girls Leila and Abbie struggle to cope with the strict rules and insidious power struggles of the institution. As a parallel to their story, there is Toni Collette as Evelyn Wade, a police officer stationed in the area who begins to investigate strange occurrences.

Themes of institutional abuse, control, and survival are what reverberate throughout the eight episodes, making it an equal psychological exploration and thriller. The mid-2000s backdrop also plays a role; pre-smartphones and ubiquitous access to the outside world, the characters are trapped in a claustrophobic and oppressive-sounding world.

Filmed on location in Ontario, Canada, the production helps to invoke that mood in an attempt to amplify the tension of the story.

Critical reaction and fan response

Rotten Tomatoes scores Wayward with a critical approval rating of some 78%, as critics have admired its ambition, genre-bending style, and reluctance to provide answers to all the questions. Star critics cite its solid performances, including Toni Collette, and suggest that the show tackles big subjects with novelty, although its pacing often proves uneven.

Audience response has varied. While ScreenRant references an audience score in the high-40s, Rotten Tomatoes' PopcornMeter as of today still shows light ratings, so the difference might not be as wide as headlines purport. Even so, first viewers note that Wayward's surreal mood and unwillingness to give easy answers render it a "love it or leave it" offer.

Streaming performance on Netflix

In terms of streaming figures, Wayward has indeed been noticed, but not necessarily in the manner implied by certain exaggerated claims. ScreenRant and FlixPatrol statistics report that the show has shown up on Netflix's Top 10 lists in various territories, even topping positions in a few markets.

Still, Netflix's own official global Top 10 reports do not include Wayward among its top worldwide sensations. This positions the show in an interesting spot: it's successful enough to generate buzz and headlines, but it can't compete with the huge, data-fueled success of other Netflix dramas like Baby Reindeer or Dahmer.

Instead, its polarizing status comes less from absolute figures and more from the nature of its storytelling and reception.

Why the "polarizing" label sticks

Then why is Wayward so divisive? The answer has to do with its execution. Critics appreciate that it does not play by the book, half thriller, half psychological drama, half social commentary, but viewers who demand neat answers may resent its refusal to define the boundaries. The material, the teen industry of trouble and institutional abuse, is dark and painful as well, which understandably detracts from its appeal.

Trending

That combination of provocative themes, bold storytelling, and mixed reactions is precisely what’s putting the show in the spotlight. While it may not be Netflix’s most polarizing thriller ever, it’s undeniably one of the most talked-about series of 2025.

Also read: Wayward Season 2 needs to happen to answer these 5 burning questions we have after the chapter 1 finale

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback