“What if you cannot have both?”: Is it possible that Ka’iana and Ka’ahumanu are fighting more than the upcoming threat in Chief of War?

Chief of War pulls us right in with the line that lingers long after it's spoken:

"What if you cannot have both?"

Ka'iana asks this question, his voice carrying the weight of choosing between war and peace.

On the surface of Chief of War, he and Ka'ahumanu appear to be fighting the same enemy i.e., the looming danger of foreign invaders and shifting alliances at home. But if you look deeper then what you get to see is that maybe the real fight is the one stirring between them.

The hidden tensions between Ka’iana and Ka’ahumanu in Chief of War

Episode 7 of Chief of War isn't only about ships, guns, or outsiders keeping a closer eye on the Hawaiian shores. It's also about cracks that have been coming up within the circle.

Ka'iana has never trusted the Europeans, not after what he's seen in Zamboanga. He knows men like Captain Metcalfe and Marley wear smiles but have and destruction in their minds. When Kamehameha leans on peace, Ka'iana fumes. He wants to do something more, even if that means cutting off the law of Mamalahoa.

This is where Ka'ahumanu's role becomes a bit more complicated than it already is. She believes in her husband's dream of peace, yet she doesn't reject Ka'iana's fears. She knows the dangers are real.

Watching her place her loyalty to Kamehameha while secretly siding with Ka'iana's outlook shows just how divided her heart and mind is. Coupled with the bond she shares with Ka'iana, a bond that seems to be something beyond friendship, makes their mission blurred.

They're supposed to fight together for the future of Hawaii, but their duality hints they might actually be fighting each other.

More than war: loyalty, betrayal, and the blurred lines

Chief of War thrives on moments where political strategy collides with personal choices.

Ka'iana risks everything by sneaking aboard Metcalfe's ship, ready to kill in order to protect his people. Yet his plan is cut short, not by foreign guns, but by betrayal from within his own household. Kupuohi, his wife, is the one who tips Kamehameha off.

Her decision isn't only about disapproval but it's also about jealousy, insecurity, and the quiet storm stirred by Ka'iana's closeness with Ka'ahumanu.

Ka'ahumanu, meanwhile, is also caught in her own impossible situation. She carries the knowledge from the prophetess that she will never bear Kamehameha's child.

She hides her sorrow with loyalty, but her eyes reveal the burden of carrying a truth that could shift her place in the kingdom. In Ka'iana, she finds an ally who not only shares her doubts about foreign men but also understands her unspoken frustrations.

The tenderness between them grows too strong to ignore in Chief of War and by the end of the episode, their connection nearly crosses a line.

The tragedy is that while Metcalfe's cannons are tearing innocent Hawaiian families apart, Ka'iana and Ka'ahumanu's struggles mirror a quieter war-one built on love, betrayal, and divided loyalties. It's not just Hawai'i under siege. Their own relationships are crumbling too.

Chief of War shows us that the greatest threats don't always come from ships on the horizon. Sometimes they rise from within. Ka'iana and Ka'ahumanu want the same thing-protection for their people but their choices and emotions may put them at odds with each other.

As the islands brace for foreign brutality, their personal storm could be just as destructive. And that's the haunting truth behind Ka'iana's question: Maybe you really cannot have both.

Trending

Stay tuned to SoapCentral for more.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback