What was Cady’s final fate in We Were Liars? Explored in depth

Cady becomes the sole survivor of the mansion fire in We Were Liars. During the blast, she is thrown out of Clairmont, the Sinclair family’s estate, into the sea. The force knocks her unconscious and causes amnesia. Throughout the season, she suffers from memory loss and is seen piecing together her traumatic past and the events of “Summer 16.”

She confronts the truth in We Were Liars finally when she discovers that she and her friends set the fire to the mansion as a protest against their toxic family legacy. Their goal was to destroy the mansion, which represents the Sinclairs. Read on to know Cady’s fate in depth.

Cady’s tragic past in We Were Liars: What she remembers

Cady and her friends’ plan to destroy Clairmont goes horribly wrong. In We Were Liars, Cady loses all her friends—Mirren, Johnny, and Gat—in the blaze, but she is thrown into the water during the blast. She suffers from amnesia but is somehow saved from the tragic event.

We Were Liars follows the twist from the novel it is based on. However, it also adds a supernatural element by portraying the Liars as real ghosts, visible not just to Cady but also to others like her aunt Carrie.This gives the entire show an eerie feel.

In Season 1, Cady experiences fragmented memories and hallucinations as a result of dissociative amnesia. All those hallucinations she believes are true—just like the viewers—but eventually she discovers the Liars aren’t alive. She was manifesting their presence, absorbed in her own guilt and sorrow.

What happens with Cady by the end of We Were Liars?

Pressured by her grandfather to uphold the family façade, Cady is offered control—at a price. Harris promises her that he will control the entire situation, but he needs her to become the Sinclair heir. Harris also threatens to expose her mistake if she refuses his offer. Here, Cady makes a tough but rightful choice—she refuses to lie anymore.

She decides to fly away from Beechwood, stealing the family boat, symbolically ending her ties with the Sinclairs. This suggests that Cady has chosen authenticity over inheritance, embracing the painful reality rather than family deception. Cadence chooses honesty and freedom over family legacy. Rejecting the Sinclair image and its lies, she tells a reporter:

"I'm just really not into fairytales anymore," and sails away from Beechwood, leaving her privileged but toxic past behind.

Trending

She’s haunted by loss, guilt, and ghostly appearances—but also beginning to heal, acknowledging the depth of her trauma. Emily Alyn Lind, speaking with TV Insider, explains her character’s step as the beginning of living a life on her own terms:

"It's just her step to sort of be able to say, 'I know that I'm not going to show up for [her grandfather] Harris, I'm not going to take his side. I'm going to walk away from all of it.'”

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback