When Love Island USA Season 7 kicked off, expectations were high. Season 6 had been a standout, with dynamic personalities and wild plot twists, so the bar was already sky-high. But it wasn’t long before viewers pinned their hopes on Huda Mustafa.
Entering third, she had charm, wit, and an energy that instantly clicked with her fellow Islanders. Her first moments with Chelley and Olandria even drew comparisons to the Powerpuff Girls trio from the previous season. She was bold. She was funny. And she was a single mom, something she revealed early on to her fellow girls, earning a wave of respect.
But in true Love Island fashion, everything changed by Episode 2. From hiding her daughter from Jeremiah to spiraling over kisses during a challenge, fans quickly began to wonder: Which Love Island is Huda on? Because it’s definitely not the one she started out in.
The Huda and Jeremiah situation heats up on Love Island USA
From the start, Huda and Jeremiah Brown had clear chemistry. Their bond ignited during a kissing challenge, and the pairing seemed inevitable. But things took a strange turn when Huda held back a key piece of her life; she didn’t tell Jeremiah she was a mom. While she explained that she wanted him to “get to know her first,” it rubbed fans the wrong way.
One moment especially stood out: when Jeremiah asked about her two-bedroom home, she danced around the subject. Instead of offering a simple answer, Huda said she’d explain later. That only made things feel more suspicious.
Viewers started asking questions, and so did Jeremiah. Was she living with someone? Was there something to hide? In a show built on quick connections, withholding a major part of your life felt like a red flag. And just like that, Love Island USA had its first major shift in public opinion.
Clingy behavior and confusion take over the villa
Things reached a boiling point when new bombshell Amaya Espinal made her move on Jeremiah. During a playful baseball game, Amaya jumped on him and planted a kiss, which is pretty standard for Love Island. But Huda did not take it well.
“She’s a b— for taking my man,” Huda reportedly said, venting to the original girls.
It didn’t matter that bombshells are literally there to stir the pot. For Huda, Jeremiah was off-limits.
Since then, any girl looking Jeremiah’s way became enemy number one in Huda’s book. Her attitude has been described as overly clingy, even possessive. Fans weren’t impressed. Love Island is known for its drama, but this wasn’t the fun kind. This was uncomfortable. And it didn’t help that Huda seemed unwilling to explore connections herself. On a show where relationships shift daily, being that territorial this early felt off.
The public turns against Huda
The online backlash hasn’t slowed down either. Fans are airing their thoughts loud and clear.
“I’m sorry but she is toxic,” one viewer bluntly wrote.
“Huda needs to go now. She is a major buzz kill and ruining the vibe,” another chimed in.
And perhaps the most pointed take of all:
“All signs point to America telling her to chill out and she takes it as a sign to go full throttle. Huda, pack it up mama.”
The verdict from social media? Viewers are tired, the villa is tense, and unless something changes fast, the pressure on Huda to leave Love Island USA might just keep growing.
Can Huda turn it around before it’s too late?
With emotions high and fans firmly divided, Huda’s future on Love Island USA is unclear. The same woman who entered the villa with warmth and confidence has quickly become the season’s most polarizing figure. And while she still has her supporters, the tide seems to have turned. What began as a story of empowerment, a single mom finding love, is now a cautionary tale in how fast things can unravel on reality TV.
Still, Love Island USA thrives on redemption arcs. Some Islanders implode and bounce back. Others fizzle out. The big question now is whether Huda can reset, reconnect, and maybe, just maybe, remind viewers why they rooted for her in the first place.
Because if she doesn’t? Fans may keep asking: Which Love Island is Huda on? And more importantly, why is she still there?