Which Twin Peaks season is the best? Ranking all three from weakest to strongest

Twin Peaks debuted on network television in 1990 and instantly became a cult phenomenon. The name of the show may confuse you into thinking it is a teenage drama like Dawson's Creek, but rest assured, it is far from that.

Twin Peaks is a murder mystery created by David Lynch and Mark Frost. FBI Agent Dale Cooper tries to solve the case of the mysterious death of high school homecoming queen Laura Palmer in Twin Peaks, Washington. What begins as a traditional whodunit quickly transforms into a bizarre cocktail of soap opera, supernatural horror, thriller, and some comedy.

Agent Cooper soon discovers that behind the smiling faces and warm nature, the residents are hiding dark secrets. Everyone is hiding something, and reality is not what it appears to be. There are forces like the mysterious BOB, the peculiar Red Room, and other hidden entities that conceal something darker and sinister.

---

Which Twin Peaks season is the best?

If Twin Peaks were a person, it would be Old Man Marley from Home Alone, the mysterious neighbor rumored to be a serial killer because of his aloof demeanor. Sadly, the show was canceled after two seasons, but its impact on modern television remained. It inspired many subsequent hit shows like The X-Files, Lost, and Stranger Things.

Its popularity prompted David Lynch to revive it for a third season that continued the show’s legacy. But not all seasons are equal. Over the years, fans have argued about which season is superior. So, today, let’s end the debate and decide which season is the best.

3) Twin Peaks: Season 2

Season two starts off at the exact point where the previous season ended. FBI Agent Dale Cooper is lying on the floor of the Great Northern Hotel after being shot by an unknown assailant. He recovers (spoiler), and midway through the show, the Palmer killers' identity is revealed, shocking the entire planet.

But just when fans thought the thrill was over, the series takes a bizarre turn. Nadine reverts to a high schooler. James gets his own strange side plot, and Ben Horne has a Civil War reenactment breakdown. Eventually, the horrific Black Lodge finale arrives, leaving fans stunned.

Now, here's why it ranks in third place. The first half of the season is an absolute chef's kiss. When the Laura Palmer mystery is finally solved, it is equally satisfying and devastating. But once the main plot concludes, the show loses momentum and begins to spiral.

The weak subplots clearly indicate that the network wanted David Lynch and Mark Frost to keep the show running. The writers were desperately trying to create episodes out of anything, and it showed. If the poor storylines weren't enough, the shift into supernatural horror proved to be the final nail in the coffin.

The last few episodes are still better than much of the second half, especially the final episode, which was directed by Lynch himself. It brings back the show’s dark and twisted tone. All in all, Season 2 is the weakest, but only by Twin Peaks standards.

2) Twin Peaks: Season 1

This is where it all began. The series starts with the discovery of the body of high school homecoming queen Laura Palmer, wrapped in plastic. FBI Agent Dale Cooper, played by the charming Kyle MacLachlan, is assigned to investigate the murder. He arrives in Twin Peaks and soon realizes that beneath the town's wholesome veneer lies a dark undercurrent.

During his investigation, he discovers that a town that seems sweet on the surface hides hideous secrets, affairs, drug rings, abusive relationships, and paranormal forces lurking in the shadows. Throughout the eight episodes, Cooper works tirelessly to solve the case, all the while being haunted by dreams of the Red Room and a dancing dwarf.

You can watch Season 1 endlessly, as it is the perfect cocktail of melodrama, murder mystery, and absurdity. Every episode is a cinematic marvel with intensity, yet enough humor to keep you engaged. The show was a pioneer in proving that even small-screen storytelling could be visually aesthetic and compelling.

So, why isn't it in the number one spot? Because it may have been a sea, but it couldn't become an ocean. It was accessible but not audacious. It was a gateway to an incredible story track that inspired many shows that followed, but it couldn't become a benchmark. Yet, it remains one of the best first seasons of any TV show ever.

1) Twin Peaks Season 3

Season 3 takes place 25 years after the events of Season 2. Agent Cooper is trapped in the Black Lodge, and his evil doppelganger, Mr. C, wreaks havoc in the real world. This time, space, time, and geography are no obstacles, as the series leaps across timelines, realities, and dimensions.

The show moves from Twin Peaks, a small town in Washington, to mega cities like Las Vegas and New York, and even an unknown void with only an eyeless woman floating around. It is an unforgettable experience, showcasing the birth of evil in atomic fire and Cooper's incredible journey.

In this reinvention, David Lynch was given full creative control, and it shows. He and Mark Frost did not attempt to cash in on nostalgia. Instead, they deconstruct the show and set the stage for cosmic storytelling. Kyle MacLachlan, meanwhile, delivers brilliant performances as Cooper, Mr. C, and Dougie Jones.

The series itself has grown older; it is quieter and lonelier. The town is haunted by the past, which lingers in the background. Every scene is a spectacle and keeps you hooked until the end. The moment when Cooper tries to "fix" time to save Laura reveals that time and luck were never in his favor.

---

Twin Peaks began as a murder mystery and evolved into a cosmic saga of bent timelines and endless dimensions. It is a show of a lifetime, setting the tone for many subsequent series. If you haven't watched it and are waiting for something spectacular, this is the show for you. The only problem is that you might not enjoy anything as much afterward.