Who is the New York Ripper in Dexter: Resurrection? Speculation explored

The identity of the New York Ripper in the television drama Dexter: Resurrection remains one of the most debated mysteries to date. Based on coded tips, ominous artifacts, and suspicious character traits, viewers scrutinize every episode, hoping to discover whether the Ripper is hiding among new members of Dexter’s inner circle or is a dark reflection of the original series.

The producers are dangling the identity of the killer whilst teasing us with nonstop hints left and right, but never actually telling us who they are.

As Dexter is sneaking around New York City, desperate for some peace, writers are adding red herrings and weaving in subplots. The murder weapon the killer left behind after his brutal work has not only haunted the city and especially the homicide unit, but also the murder club of billionaire Leon Prater. Notably, Prater keeps the Ripper’s old murder weapon in a vault. Everyone wants to see it, maybe even steal it, but that item might be the one small detail that unlocks the whole case.

It is this complicated game of cat and mouse that has made the question, Who is the New York Ripper? the cultural centerpiece of the Dexter revival, in addition to Dexter himself and his blood secrets.

---

Who is the New York Ripper in Dexter: Resurrection?

The main suspects in the middle of the speculation are under the spotlight, each having evidence and theories to prove their guilt. Creators have designed the Ripper reveal to be a season-long mystery, delighting fans with minute clues but still never really tearing down the curtain altogether.

Detective Claudette Wallace

One of the most believable suspects in Dexter: Resurrection has been Detective Claudette Wallace (played by Kadia Saraf). The fact that Wallace was obsessed with finding a solution to the Ripper case cannot be overstated, since it takes her to the dark depths of the investigation, even at the risk of her own life. Fan theories suggest that Wallace is pursuing a significant case because she herself leads a dual life: could her expertise stem from experience, not just research?

It wouldn’t be the first time a show pulled that move; remember Dexter? The ones you thought were the hunters ended up being the monsters.

Charley (Uma Thurman)

Leon Prater has an enigmatic right hand in the form of Charley (played by Uma Thurman), and we are taken through the circles of the city's elite killers. The fact that she was aware of the murder club run by Prater and was too close to the weapon mainly used by the Ripper raises suspicion. As the alliances within the club begin to break down, Charley, having played a shadowy role for all, has sparked doubts that she is the true murderer operating behind the scenes.

Jonah Mitchell

A few fans speculate that Jonah Mitchell is the Ripper, connecting the overall story of the original series to Dexter: Resurrection. This possible link is based on his familiarity with Dexter and his personal history with trauma and violence. The reason relates to Jonah's tragic past; the murder weapon, a manhole cover lifting hook, is an appropriate symbol of his long-standing hostility.

Blessing Kamara

Blessing Kamara (Ntare Guma Mbaho Mwine), another suspect, is a dark horse among fans due to some recent plot twists in Dexter: Resurrection. Kamara's dark past and evasive nature have made him an intriguing possibility. His connections with Wallace and Miami Metro’s Angel Batista have created a web of potential motives that remain to be uncovered on television.

Showrunners have hinted at an explosive ending for Dexter: Resurrection since its season premiere. Still, writers have deliberately added uncertainty to each suspect’s profile in case they are not the killer.

---

More about the show

Dexter: Resurrection starts after the events of Dexter: New Blood, with Dexter Morgan (Michael C. Hall) waking up in New York after the supposedly fatal gunshot from his son. Guilt and the desire for redemption motivate Dexter to find his son Harrison, who is growing up in darkness surrounded by new threats and old enemies.

The season dives into the rebuilding of his life, the escape of Miami Metro’s Angel Batista, and his entry into the secret group of killers led by Leon Prater. The Ripper’s shadow looms everywhere, and it feels like every episode can’t help but emphasize that dark legacy. You’ve got Dexter, completely obsessed, and then Prater’s small murder-nerd club feeding off the same twisted past.

A paramount twist in the tale comes about when Dexter comes to learn about the Ripper murder weapon in the collection of Prater, linking the ongoing mystery to both Prater and the city’s police department.

Cast and release

Co-created by Michael C. Hall and showrunner David Hollander, Dexter: Resurrection was released on Paramount+ with Showtime on July 11, 2025. It stars Michael C. Hall returning as Dexter Morgan, along with Kadia Saraf as Claudette Wallace, Peter Dinklage as Leon Prater, Ntare Guma Mbaho Mwine as Blessing Kamara, and Uma Thurman, who is revealed in the series to be Charley.

The show has received a strong reaction from both critical and enthusiastic audiences, who have applauded its tough edge and numerous layers of mystery, particularly its more elusive Ripper arc.

With the finale of Dexter: Resurrection right around the corner, everyone is wondering if we’ll finally get some answers or just more theories to obsess over until Season 2. Are they going to spill the big secret, or just mess with us again?

All the spotlight is on Dexter, his kid, and that mysterious killer lurking in the background, just waiting to steal the show, or maybe ruin everyone’s day.

The final episode is expected to air on August 29, 2025.