Netflix just put out a three-part docuseries called Fit for TV: The Reality of The Biggest Loser, and it has got people talking about just how risky weight-loss shows can really be. Fit for TV looks back at the hit competition that ran for 18 seasons between 2004 and 2020, where contestants battled to drop as many pounds as possible for a $250,000 prize. Directed by Skye Borgman, the doc brings together stories from past contestants, trainers, producers, and health experts, and what they share isn’t pretty.
On screen, celebrity trainers Jillian Michaels and Bob Harper were famous for pushing people through punishing workouts and strict diets. But off-screen, things were even tougher. The doc uncovers that many contestants ended up with scary health problems like organ failure, severe dehydration, and even muscle breakdown that could have been deadly. Former players reveal drastic means they used to win, frequently disregarding medical advice and risking severe health harm.
The series also explores the absence of long-term assistance for candidates once shooting has concluded. Many participants regained the weight they lost throughout the show, indicating that the procedures were unsustainable. It also explores questions regarding television's duty for participant well-being and whether entertainment value should take precedence over health concerns. These insights come at a time when society is reconsidering the harmful diet culture and unrealistic body ideals propagated by the media.
In the end, The Biggest Loser wasn’t just about dropping weight; it sometimes meant losing your health, too.
Fit for TV: The Biggest Loser’s issues detailed
Season eight contestant Tracey Yukich suffered rhabdomyolysis during a running challenge, a severe condition where muscles break down and release toxic substances into the bloodstream. She collapsed and required a helicopter evacuation to a hospital. Yukich revealed on Fit for TV that:
"My organs were literally shutting down."
The condition affected her liver and kidneys before threatening her heart. She described feeling like she had died during the medical emergency.
Season one winner Ryan Benson also experienced dangerous health effects. He found blood in his urine after extreme dehydration from restrictive eating and intense exercise. Benson admitted to consuming only lemon juice, maple syrup, and cayenne pepper during his final ten days of competition.
Fit for TV exposes shocking tactics contestants used to achieve dramatic results. Benson's master cleanse diet violated basic nutritional guidelines but helped him secure victory. Medical professionals would classify such practices as dangerous.
Rachel Frederickson's transformation particularly alarmed viewers and trainers alike. She dropped from 260 pounds to 105 pounds, leaving her body appearing "emaciated." Trainer Bob Harper described feeling "horror" when seeing her final appearance.
The extreme nature of these transformations raises questions about whether the show prioritized television drama over participant safety. Critics argue that such rapid weight loss methods are medically inadvisable and potentially life-threatening. Former contestants claim trainers encouraged them to ignore medical advice and push beyond safe limits. Social media critics have called for accountability from both celebrity trainers and production companies.
The show's structure appeared to reward extreme behavior rather than sustainable health practices. Contestants felt pressure to achieve dramatic weekly weight loss numbers regardless of health consequences.
Executive producer David Broome acknowledged the lack of long-term support for contestants after filming concluded. He cited financial constraints as the primary barrier to providing ongoing care. He explained:
"We would have loved to have aftercare, but we're a television show without endless pots of money."
NBC declined to fund extended support programs for participants. This absence of follow-up care contributed to many contestants regaining lost weight. The pattern suggests the show's methods were unsustainable for long-term health maintenance.
The cultural impact of the show and its relevance in today’s time
Fit for TV arrives as society confronts "Ozempic culture" and renewed pressure for thinness through social media platforms like "SkinnyTok." These tendencies reflect the poisonous body image ideals that The Biggest Loser propagated during its peak popularity.
The series mirrored larger 2000s views towards weight loss, valuing quick results over long-term health habits. Modern viewers can now identify the detrimental messages inherent in the show's framework.
Fit for TV demonstrates how the entertainment industry's objectives may trump fundamental health and safety concerns. It is a cautionary story regarding excessive weight loss practices and poor participant safety. While The Biggest Loser achieved strong ratings, the human cost looks to be significant and long-term.
The series raises critical concerns regarding media accountability and the ethics of transformational reality television.
Fit for TV: The Reality of The Biggest Loser is now streaming on Netflix.