Why Jenny & Sumit’s story feels out of sync with 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way’s original Premise

The return of seasoned characters Jenny Slatten and Sumit Singh in 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way raises both expectations and scrutiny. The plotline of Jenny & Sumit primarily focuses on financial stress, family difficulties, and cultural resistance, but in reverse, whereas the conventional focus of this spin-off is Americans moving to strange, culturally different nations and finding it difficult to assimilate. The purpose of the show is to document the foreigner's adjustment to a new environment, but Jenny is by no means a newcomer.

Jenny has already lived in India for years, so she is not constantly overwhelmed by the local culture. She is not the fish out of water, but rather someone who refuses to swim, as evidenced by the several scenes in which she defies conventional expectations, such as performing household tasks or completely integrating with Sumit's family. Meanwhile, Sumit's family becomes the "adapting" side instead of Jenny, flipping the American-in-strange-land premise. The narrative of the season is strained by this inversion.

This article will examine why the plot of Jenny & Sumit seems out of sync with the original idea of 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way. We'll look at how Jenny's defiance of social expectations, their relationship's power dynamics, and how their hardships are framed change the show's thematic focus, and why seasoned viewers could find this change startling.

How Jenny & Sumit’s arc disrupts 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way’s core premise

From cultural outsider to cultural rebel

In 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way, the American partner enters a foreign country and must adjust to, understand, and navigate unfamiliar and frequently difficult cultural conventions. However, Jenny is already a part of Indian culture. In the show, she is portrayed as actively resisting rather than learning.

Despite spending years in India, Jenny's plot frequently demonstrates that she "refused to adhere to the cultural norms." She is less of a fish out of water and more of a cultural hacker, pushing limits she wants to redefine since she is reluctant to help out around the house or follow family rules.

This changes the balance of power: rather than demonstrating adaptation, the story demands that society change to accommodate her. The original tension that results from adaptation under pressure is diluted, and the feel of the show is altered whenever the plot revolves around defiance rather than assimilation.

Power, ownership, & whose story is it?

The division of narrative agency between Jenny and Sumit is another way their arcs diverge. Homesickness, adjustment, and cultural shock are all major aspects of the American journey in the majority of other countries.

Much of the drama in Jenny & Sumit, however, is on Sumit's family's tolerance of Jenny, arguments about independence, and disputes over tasks. This arrangement gives Jenny and Sumit a stronger sense of belonging on Happily Ever After? than on The Other Way.

This change affects the balance of power: Sumit is frequently seen as passive or accommodating, whereas Jenny is depicted as entitled, uncooperative, or incapable of making concessions. Thus, the show presents culture as the arena in which individual control is fought. This framing undermines the 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way premise, which holds that conflict arises not from challenging what one side already knows but rather from immersion, language barriers, traditions, and humbling growth.

Trending

Stay tuned to follow Sumit and Jenny's story on 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way on TLC.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback