Why Morticia Addams chose to burn Goody’s spell book over sealing the deal with her mother in Wednesday Season 2? Details explored 

In Wednesday Season 2, Episode 4, titled “If These Woes Could Talk,” we see Morticia Addams struggling with a somewhat classic Addams-style dilemma: take her mother, Hester Frump’s, unusually generous offer to make a substantial donation at the Nevermore gala in exchange for giving Goody’s spellbookback to Wednesday or burn the darn book altogether and make a statement. She picks the flower. It is a gasp-and-blink moment, which goes beyond drama. It shows what sort of a parent Morticia is to her children. Instead of pursuing power, shortcuts, or family politics, she draws boundaries and extends her protection to her kids, even though this temporarily places her as a villain in her daughter’s life.

Morticia's concerns and reasons

Morticia does not burn Goody's Book of Shadows because she despises magic. She burns it because she knows where untempered psychic ambition will lead. Episode 4 finally fills in on the backstory of the family: Aunt Ophelia at one time pushed her Raven gifts too far and consequently was overcome with a state aptly described as psychic exhaustion. It was so intense that it caused pain accompanied by black tears until Grandmama sent her off to the Willow Hill Psychiatric Hospital. Morticia implored her mother not to pack away her sister, who needed guidance, not treatment, but Hester did not budge on her decision.

And now it is Wednesday who is treading on the same razor-edge path with worn-out visions and heightened stakes, thinking that a magical solution in Goody’s book will solve her problems in a beat. That isn't a solution; that is like taking a jet pack to a forest fire. Thus, by burning the book, Morticia, as a mother, is merely trying to break the cycle her own mother failed or refused to. It is protective and not punitive.

The deal with Grandmama

At the Jericho Camp, Wednesday challenged Morticia to a blind duel, “el duelo a ciegas,” with the condition that if she won, Morticia would have to return the book, and if she lost, Morticia would burn it. And as we know, it was Morticia who won the fight. As one last attempt at retrieving the book, Wednesday persuades her grandmama to approach her mother.

The sour relationship between Morticia and Hester comes out in full swing when Grandmama walks through the door, making a grand gesture of donating a hefty amount at the Nevermore gala, but with one concession, however: Morticia must hand over the spellbook to Wednesday. It seems generous, but it is, in reality, a power stunt that aims at diminishing Morticia's authority and would unintentionally push Wednesday towards a perilous side of magic. Morticia looks right through it.

Returning the book would no doubt please both Wednesday and Grandmama, but it would also risk Wednesday’s life. Morticia refuses to do it; no bargains, no concessions, no dirty tricks, and eventually tosses the book into the fire. The act is realistic and symbolic: by standing her ground, she sends the message that she is not someone who can be easily manipulated, nor is Wednesday’s safety an aspect of trade, even with family. Her line “My family is non-negotiable” becomes a statement of her mission for this season and also sounds like a throat-clearing clap-back to the transactional parenting of her mother.

What it means for Wednesday

To Wednesday, her mother's actions feel like sabotage. Her visions are not trustworthy, the mysteries are piling up, and it seemed that Goody had found the most evident way to answer her psychic shortcomings through the Book of Shadows. Wednesday was even willing to fight over it, and she did, literally, in a blindfolded Addams duel against Morticia, only to lose the bet, which gave Morticia the right to burn the book upon her victory.

In Episode 4, when Morticia goes through with her decision to destroy the book, Wednesday is no longer left with a shortcut but the more difficult, long, risk-averse path to the truth that forces her to fall back on people (ugh), legwork (double ugh), and her own instincts, instead of a spectral crutch. Thematically, the fire drove Wednesday towards agency and not dependency; practically, it prodded the investigation into Willow Hill, Stonehurst, and the threat of the strange birds without the promise of fast-fix spells.

Trending

For more such insights on Wednesday, keep following Soapcentral.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback