Why Sofia Falcone was sent to Arkham in The Penguin? Details explored

The Penguin has been nothing short of a dark, twisted ride through the roads of Gotham, but episode 4, 'Cent'Anni,' is where the roads deepen and grow darker around Sofia Falcone. Her being in the Arkham State Hospital is not just another side subplot; it is the very trauma that shapes her into Oz's most dangerous rival.

Sofia ends up at Arkham after being framed by her own father and tortured by the system, a turn of events that explains her fractured, merciless side in the series.

Let's take a deeper look at her story, right now, right here.

---

A daughter betrayed: The setup behind Sofia’s Arkham fate in The Penguin

Before the walls of Arkham, Sofia Falcone's fall began right at home. As Gotham's mob boss, Carmine Falcone's daughter, she had always carried the weight of having to deliver family loyalty. But when there were whispers about her father's involvement in her mother's death, things started to spiral. Instead of protecting her, Carmine chose to silence her.

By the end of the fourth episode, it is revealed that he framed Sofia for brutal murders, including that of a journalist named Summer Gleeson. This betrayal marked the real beginning of her imprisonment.

Although Sofia insisted she wasn't guilty, Gotham's corrupt system didn't care. Testimonies from the past, even childhood behavior, were twisted into evidence against her. Her fate was sealed not because of the crimes themselves but because her father decided she had to be removed.

The irony is chilling: Carmine's choice to lock her away actually pushed her closer to becoming the very monster Gotham believed she already was.

---

Inside Arkham: The torture, trauma, and transformation

What followed at Arkham was a descent no one could come out of unchanged. Instead of temporary treatment, Sofia was subjected to relentless abuse. The episode shows her enduring electroshock therapy repeatedly, and the six months she was meant to spend there stretched into a nightmare with no end in sight.

Director Helen Shaver explained in an interview with Deadline that the focus wasn't just on showing pain but on exploring:

"Once I’d read episode four, I was just like, ‘okay, I’m doing this.’ I so understood the journey to the primal trauma and the unraveling of this woman, her rebirth."

Showrunner Lauren LeFranc agreed with this sentiment, telling the outlet that it was important to slow the story down and truly and fully dive into Sofia's psychology. She admitted that it might have felt a bit too odd to spend so much time on her in a show called The Penguin, but she also stressed that understanding Sofia was the path into understanding Oz as well.

For actress Cristin Milioti, who plays Sofia, the experience was transformative. She described the shoot as a "real; pinch-me experience" and added:

"We needed to see Sofia driven mad. She becomes the thing that everyone accused her of being."

By the time Arkham was done with her, Sofia was no longer just a victim, and she was reborn into Gotham's feared "Hangman."

---

The difference between the comics and what it means for The Penguin

Die-hard DC fans will recognize Sofia Falcone from Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale's The Long Halloween and Dark Victory, where she was revealed to be the Hangman killer targeting Gotham police officers. But The Penguin takes her story in a more tragic and much more layered direction.

Instead of choosing murder from the start, this version of Sofia in The Penguin is pushed into darkness due to betrayal, torture, and abandonment. Being falsely accused of her father's crimes adds weight to her vendetta and deepens her conflict with Oz.

What makes this character so interesting is how she, in a way, subverts all of the expectations. In Gotham, villains are usually born from ambition or obsession, but Sofia's villainy is bred from pain.

Sofia's rage is not random, and it is rooted in being betrayed by family, abandoned by society, and brutalized in Arkham. By the time she leaves, she fully embraces the role everyone forced on her, becoming the unflinching antagonist Oz Cobbs now has to face.

For a show like The Penguin, Sofia's journey stands out as one of the most important and defining pieces of the storytelling.

---

Sofia Falcone's time in Arkham is the turning point that explains everything about her in The Penguin. She was framed by her father, brutalized by the system, and reshaped into Gotham's Hangman against her will. Her tragedy doesn't just deepen her character, but it also sets her up as OZ's greatest rival.

With The Penguin being built on betrayal and power, Sofia's descent into Arkham proves that Gotham doesn't just create monsters, it manufactures them.

---

Stay tuned to Soap Central for more.