Why did Sofia kidnap Francis Cobblepot when she could’ve easily killed her in The Penguin? Details explored

The Penguin is one of the most electrifying battles for power in Gotham, opposing Oswald Cobblepot in a fight to the death. Francis Cobblepot is kidnapped by Sofia Falcone in the show, catching viewers by surprise who had anticipated Sofia's cunning ruthlessness, typical of the organized crime cartels in Gotham.

As it happens, history doesn't necessarily repeat, but it does rhyme. That's the only way to describe The Penguin. Everything that happens is never without a reason, and everything that is done is done on purpose. Sofia's kidnappings of Francis can be seen more as strategic maneuvers than acts of clemency.

Whether it was leverage, intimidation, or finally domination as the goal, the action altered the power relationship between Sofia and Oswald.

---

Power in Gotham is more than violence

One of The Penguin's motifs that continually recurs is that power does not always originate from killing enemies. By leaving Francis alive, Sofia Falcone guaranteed that Oswald was emotionally exploitable.

If she had killed Francis, Oswald would have probably been free of that psychological grip and acted in raw anger. Since she was alive, however, he was also cautious, equivocal, and manipulable.

---

Psychological pressure over finality

Francis Cobblepot's weakness is greater than hers as Oswald's mother; she is his vulnerability and his humanity. For Sofia, keeping her hostage at The Penguin would be a mind game.

Instead of assassinating Francis, Sofia imprisoned her as a show of Oswald's weakness. This was to keep him under pressure instead of assassinating him and giving him closure.

---

Long-term strategy in The Penguin

Crime dramas have always proved that the villains prefer to have leverage rather than short-term solutions. Sofia's decision aligns with the plan. A hostage can be employed during negotiations, as leverage in games, or even used as a destabilizing element against rivals.

Killing Francis would have been irreversible, but keeping her alive preserved Sofia's leverage for use in the future. While the series does not so much as depict her precise motive, the long-term strategic benefit is obvious.

---

Francis Cobblepot's role

Francis is not a cameo; she's there to reveal to us the vulnerability of Oswald's character. Francis's presence in The Penguin, makes us realize the personal investment Oswald makes in his climb to power, and so, Francis is the perfect pawn for villains.

Sofia's utilization of Francis also illustrates how close personal relationships end up being turned into a tool of warfare in Gotham. Here, even familial relationships are turned around on individuals as part of the grand war of conquest.

---

Keeping suspense in the story

Narratively, kidnapping rather than murder retains suspense. Uncertain fate for Francis creates suspense among readers, with each subsequent installment in equilibrium.

Summaries and criticisms noted how seriality maintains tension, preventing Sofia's battle against Oswald from concluding too quickly. It is a choice well worth making for characterization justification as well as narrative necessity.

---

Back to Gotham's survival laws

Gotham's always a city where violence and manipulation are equal. The Penguin is just so devoted to that maxim. Sofia's action is restraint, waiting, and the ability to recognize fear as stronger than killing. In an era of flexible allegiance and secret motive, intimidation control is stronger than instant killing.

---

Sofia Falcone's kidnapping of Francis Cobbleport is The Penguin's masterstroke. It demonstrates that power in Gotham isn't comprised of some single monolithic act of brutality; it's keeping your grip.

Whether interpreted as strategy, as bludgeoning, or as a means of taking Oswald out of play, the act itself is a metaphor for the show's broader themes: survival not necessarily on strength but by brains and patience.

Also read: What happened to Jack and Benny in The Penguin? Details explored