Why True Detective’s first season still outshines every other crime drama

True Detective season 1 debuted ten years ago and continues to hold its legacy as one of the greatest seasons of any show ever made in its genre. This season of the show stands apart its creative force and the career-defining performances.

Added to this combination of talent, narrative depth, and technical brilliance was a unique storytelling style that forged a niche for itself in anthology television.

Season 1 not only set the ambience in motion but also introduced the central characters. Matthew McConaughey outshined as Rust Cohle, the cynical, philosophical detective and Woody Harrelson brought his own grounded charm as Marty Hart.

---

Why True Detective’s first season still outshines every other crime drama

The masterful synergy of talent

The emotional center of this show was Marty and Cohle as they navigated a whirlwind of eerie, chilling serial killings in Louisiana. The friendship in season 1 was nuanced, with a contrast between Rust's fatalistic philosophy and Marty's more conventional hypocrisy.

The dialogues were written masterfully by the team working behind the lens. They reflected the soul and substance of these two central characaters. This dialogue from Rust sums up his philosophy:

"This is a world where nothing is solved. You know, someone once told me time is a flat circle. Everything we’ve ever done or will do, we’re gonna do over and over and over again."

This contrast between two integral characters builds much of the narrative tension as the crimes get more and more gory and complicated. The synergy was not only limited to on-screen pairs but also in what went behind the lens. True Detective was one of the very rare creative models in which a single writer, Nic Pizzolatto, and a single director, Cary Joji Fukunaga, oversaw the entire season.

---

Unique narrative complexity beyond the mystery

Beyond the on-screen and off-screen synergies, True Detective’s Season 1 brought to the audience a troubling narrative complexity. The show flips the script with how it re-imagines detective storytelling: not through profiling and criminal investigation only but through the psychological landscapes of Rust and Marty.

While other shows like Law & Order, CSI had a very different appeal, True Detective left us with more discomfort than answers and resolutions. The mysteries opened the stage for deeper philosophical meditations than just cat and mouse dynamics between the killer and the detectives.

For example, the central, fuelling force of the plot is the investigation into a ritualistic murder linked to the "Yellow King". The narrative is divided into two distinct timelines, shifting between present-day police interviews in 2012 to frame flashbacks to the original 1995 investigation, allowing viewers to observe the slow fallout between the lead characters.

As the show progressed towards later seasons this brilliance of writing and storytelling became blunt, lacking in the slow paced patience that season 1 had.

---

The enduring legacy of technical and thematic excellence

True Detective season 1 also stood out in its visual and auditory craftsmanship. Forged with meticulous details, these effects left a lasting, impactful atmosphere that stayed with us even after the credits rolled.

Only a few shows in this genre have been able to pull this off so neatly as Season 1 of this crime drama. The long, six-minute, single-take tracking shot in the episode titled Who Goes There stands as a glaring proof of this claim. Beyond just a technical stunt, the scene added rawness to the storytelling, bringing the audience right into the middle of chaos.

The world-building also deserves praise. Small, nuanced details like Rust's unorthodox methods for investigation brought an air of realism into the story. Added to this excellent blend of devices was T. Bone Burnett’s ominous score and the carefully curated soundtracks. These gave the first season a unique, benchmark identity playing a key role in highlighting and carrying forward the undeniably mythical appeal of the story.

---

Where True Detective made a difference?

True Detective refused to walk the path of established crime drama conventions. Even though it has its own flaws and loopholes in the later seasons, Season 1 really delivered on the demand for a mind-bending thriller.

Other popular shows often end up overcrowding the story with numerous characters and needless arcs. But this season of the show remained true to its voice and vision, offering a neat, gritty crime drama that carved a niche for itself.

Also read: Every major character death in Sons of Anarchy, ranked by shock factor