Sheila Baskin is one of the most vibrant clients in All’s Fair. The show revolves around a group of female divorce lawyers who establish their own firm, and Sheila appears as a client of Liberty Ronson.She is the wife of a cosmetics business tycoon. When she cheats on her husband due to his emotional unavailability, the billionaire threatens her. Actress Judith Light has earnestly played this role and made Sheila one of the most memorable clients on the show.Now that the series has been renewed, fans are wondering if Sheila Baskin will return in All’s Fair Season 2. Unfortunately, the answer is no. Judith Light has confirmed that after making recurring appearances in Season 1, she will not be seen in Season 2 of the Hulu series.Sheila Baskin will not return in All’s Fair Season 2 View this post on Instagram Instagram PostJudith Light recently had an interview with TheWrap, during which she confirmed that she will not return as Sheila Baskin in All’s Fair Season 2. However, she added that she is happy for her co-stars on the show’s renewal:“I was delighted for [the cast]. I went in there as a guest star. I’m not part of that second season, but for the gals who I adore — like Niecy Nash [Betts] and Naomi Watts and Kim [Kardashian] and Glenn [Close] and Sarah [Paulson] and the team, and Ryan [Murphy] — [I] just love. Really, I’m so happy for them.”In All’s Fair Episode 1, Liberty learns that Sheila’s billionaire husband, Theodore Baskin, is threatening her and using their prenup to trap her. Sheila admits to Liberty that she had an affair because Theodore had long stopped showing her affection.She showcases a massive jewellery collection worth $40 million that Theodore had gifted her on different occasions. Liberty tells her that the collection legally belongs to her as per California laws. Sheila eventually decides to auction the jewelry, and the event is attended by the lawyers.Judith also talked about her character during the interview, and revealed that Sheila was created due to a collaborative effort between her, series creator Ryan Murphy, and costume designer Lou Eyrich. She said:“I never create a character alone. I am always creating with my fellow actors. I’m also creating [with the designers and crew]. It’s like two people, together, make a baby. Two people, together, make the character. A lot of that stuff on All’s Fair really comes down [to] — Ryan Murphy is a visionary. A lot of that stuff comes down to him, but it’s Lou Eyrich who is the costume designer.”The series premiered on Hulu at the beginning of November 2025. It received largely negative reviews from the critics who panned it for its soapy nature and predictable story. However, that did not stop it from becoming a success among viewers. The series recorded one of the most-watched premieres on Hulu, which led to its quick renewal for a second season.All’s Fair airs new episodes on Hulu on Tuesdays.