Demon Slayer didn't need the reincarnation for the ending to be memorable

The final chapter of Demon Slayer did not disappoint. However, it could have been even better. While many admired seeing their precious characters find peace in new lives, others felt the reincarnation twist undermined the emotional weight of their sacrifices. The manga's conclusion jumped forward to modern-day Tokyo, displaying descendants and reincarnated versions of the Hashira living peaceful lives as ordinary citizens.

This ending preference, though well-intentioned, wasn't essential to making a memorable finale. Demon Slayer had already established such a powerful emotional footing through its characters' journeys that a simple epilogue showing the survivors rebuilding their lives would have been equally impactful. The story proved those sacrifices were meaningful without bringing anyone back to life.

The series succeeded because readers formed deep connections with characters like Rengoku, Shinobu, and Tokito. Their deaths carried weight precisely because they were irreversible. When Rengoku smiled through his last moments or when Shinobu's poison finally defeated Doma, it packed a punch. The reincarnation chapter inadvertently diluted these moments by suggesting death wasn't truly the end.

The manga's strength lay in showing how loss shapes the living. Tanjiro's growth after losing his family, Zenitsu's courage inspired by his fallen comrades, and Inosuke's learning compassion through tragedy—these character arcs were complete without needing spiritual resurrection.

The time-skip to contemporary Japan felt disconnected from the story's core. Seeing Tanjiro's descendant doing parkour to school or Zenitsu's great-grandchild dismissing demon slayer history as "science fiction" created an odd tonal shift. Demon Slayer stood out thanks to its unique Taisho-era backdrop and deep historical feel.

The modern setting also raised uncomfortable questions about the characters' legacies. When future generations treat the demon slayers' sacrifices as fairy tales, their memory is diminished rather than honored. This wasn't the triumphant celebration fans deserved after following these characters through life-and-death battles.

What could have been a better ending?

A more grounded epilogue would have served Demon Slayer better. Imagine seeing Tanjiro and Nezuko rebuilding their family home, or Giyu finally learning to connect with others after the war. These quiet moments of healing would have provided closure without needing supernatural elements.

The series could have shown how the surviving characters honored their fallen friends through their actions. Perhaps Tanjiro becomes a teacher to pass down breathing techniques, or the remaining Hashira establishes schools to train new generations. These tangible legacies would have felt more authentic than distant reincarnations.

Even the long-awaited revelation about the blue spider lily felt anticlimactic. Learning that Muzan couldn't find the flower because it only bloomed during daylight was a clever irony, but it came too late to matter. This information might have created interesting plot developments if revealed earlier, but as a final-chapter reveal, it felt like an afterthought.

The explanation also emphasized how much remained unknown in the original timeline. Rather than jumping to the future, it could have delved more in-depth into the aftermath of Muzan's defeat and the world's reconstruction.

Trending

Great endings don't need grand gestures to be memorable. At times, the strongest endings are the ones told in silence. The series had already confirmed that small moments—a shared meal, a gentle conversation, a moment of understanding between enemies—could carry immense, moving significance.

In the end, Demon Slayer didn’t need to ensure happy climaxes for everyone to be pleasing. ife doesn’t present such assurances, and the series’ grounded approach to tragedy and loss was part of its charm. The reincarnation twist moved away from this authentic emotional core. The manga's ending remains a topic of passionate discussion among fans, which proves its impact regardless of individual opinions.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback