Fans still puzzled as Sydney Sweeney says her Met Gala look was a tribute to 1968’s The Legend of Lylah Clare

Sydney Sweeney wore a custom Miu Miu black shiny dress at the 2025 Met Gala, and her look quickly became the hot topic. She said her outfit was inspired by an old movie from 1968 called The Legend of Lylah Clare. Sydney said her dress was a tribute to that character and her dramatic story.

But many fans were left confused. They didn’t really understand the connection between her outfit and the theme of the night. Some thought the look didn’t match the dress code. Others just didn’t get the movie reference at all.

Many were confused about how her outfit linked to the theme of the night, which was “Superfine: Tailoring Black Style.” While Sydney Sweeney clearly had a creative idea in mind, the internet had other thoughts. People on social media quickly started talking about her look. Some said it was beautiful, while others felt it didn’t match the theme at all. A lot of users admitted they had never even heard of The Legend of Lylah Clare before Sydney mentioned it.

---

Fan Reactions on Sydney Sweeney's Met Gala Look

The mix of confusion and curiosity turned Sydney Sweeney's red carpet moment into a hot topic. Now, the internet is full of jokes, opinions, and questions about what her dress really meant. Some fans are defending her bold choice, while others are still trying to figure it out.

The user @ryanranime commented,

"The theme is black fashion but she chose to pay homage a white women?"

Another user @mysterious_wini cpmmented,

"Still not the theme. Was supposed to be in honor of black not white"

An user @afladesvision commented,

"I’ll be the first to say f*ck the theme when I’m looking at the picture of Sydney"

The user @MollyP25131886 commented,

"The theme was black fashion and something to do with tailoring?? Yeah well I'd be with Sydney because I read that to be something nicely tailored, in black."

An user @vivixnojim commented,

"I don’t like what she did here but the dress itself… lovely."

Another user @LadyLuh24 commented,

"But they did say that the theme this year isn’t just about taylored suits and ties, or big hats. Atleast she is different, she may have approached the theme in a different way. Plus she does look good."

The user @livxttiche commented,

"This look whispers old Hollywood with a scream of modern boldness"

As you can see, fans are all over the place with their thoughts. Some people are praising her beauty, while others are scratching their heads. A few are even turning the confusion into jokes, saying they need to watch the movie now just to understand what she meant.

---

Why Sydney Sweeney's Look Got So Confusing

There are a few reasons why Sydney Sweeney's look puzzled so many people. First, The Legend of Lylah Clare is not a well-known film. It came out more than 50 years ago and wasn’t a huge hit. So, when Sydney Sweeney mentioned it, a lot of fans were hearing the name for the first time.

Second, her dress had no clear signs connecting it to the movie. There was no big clue or reference in the outfit that screamed “Lylah Clare.” It just looked like a fancy black dress. That made people wonder how it fit the story of an old movie.

Third, the Met Gala theme this year focused on “Superfine: Tailoring Black Style.” It was about Black fashion and representation. Some thought her look didn’t match that idea, while others said it could still work if you stretched the meaning a bit. Still, there is one thing everyone can agree on - Sydney Sweeney knows how to get people talking.