A 16-hour season format for The Walking Dead will lead to this major casting problem (but Scott M. Gimple is more than up for it)

The Walking Dead ( Image via Instagram / @ thewalkingdead )
The Walking Dead ( Image via Instagram / @ thewalkingdead )

After eleven grueling seasons, The Walking Dead might have finally concluded its central narrative, but that does not necessarily mean the universe is slowing down. Spin-offs such as Dead City, Daryl Dixon, and The Ones Who Live are all flourishing in their respective niches of the apocalypse, and fans are already hypothesizing what a hypothetical twelfth season might hold. One of the largest debates is format, particularly whether the show goes back to the old 16-episode standard. Sounds ambitious. But is it still feasible in the current television landscape?

A 16-episode season was perfect when The Walking Dead was at its best — when the cast was largely set, ratings were off the charts, and there was more stability off-camera. Flash forward to today, and it's a lot more fragmented. The franchise is expanding in various directions, and the actors are more booked than ever with other projects and spin-off commitments. So what happens when you attempt to draw multiple leads from various shows back into a 16-hour arc? That's where things begin to get hairy.


The Walking Dead's original format is a double-edged sword

Historically, The Walking Dead prospered with its 16-episode split-season approach. It provided the show with sufficient space to develop arcs, continue character development, and venture into new communities. With the franchise now branching out into spin-offs and limited series, however, the formerly successful format may now be more hindrance than a help. Coordinating all those hours of material takes not only a compelling story but a deeply invested ensemble cast, which the franchise no longer always has in one location.

Cast members such as Norman Reedus, Danai Gurira, and Lauren Cohan now have their own spin-off show, each with a separate shooting schedule and creative vision. If the flagship show came back in a full-season format, it would be a scheduling disaster trying to get all of their schedules aligned. And besides that, these actors have projects outside of the Walking Dead universe as well. The longer season would require more time on set, which may not be an option for everyone.


Spin-off pledges make a complete reunion more difficult

The increasing spin-offs, although thrilling for viewers, make it even more difficult to logistically bring back the original cast for 16 episodes. Dead City, Daryl Dixon, and The Ones Who Live are all functioning as separate storylines, frequently happening in alternate timelines and locations. Merging those arcs into a single season of The Walking Dead would require not just tremendous coordination but also narrative exposition — something that may not be possible to do without straining credulity.

All of these series have their own production schedules, which tend to overlap or clash with one another. Having everyone congregate in a regular season would result in either halting the spin-offs or heavily restricting character inclusion. That's a lot to balance, particularly when viewers anticipate high-stakes storytelling and regular character inclusion. Simply put, the longer the season, the more fragmented the casting.


Scott M. gimple is confronted with a special creative challenge

Scott M. Gimple, the franchise head of content, is familiar with logistical challenges. He has seen The Walking Dead grow into a full-fledged universe over the years, synchronizing timelines, crossover events, and character development across shows in multiple series. Nevertheless, even for someone who is familiar with it, coordinating a 16-episode mainline season with three or more spin-offs is a challenging task. It's not so much about creativity and more about pragmatics — ensuring that everyone's availability is coordinated and the story isn't hurt by erratic casting.

Nevertheless, Gimple has demonstrated that he's flexible. His strategy during the post-season-11 period has been to trend towards tight mini-series and character-based arcs. A complete reverting to 16 episodes would constitute a major departure from this model. Although he might be able to coordinate such an endeavor, the configuration of the franchise might not accommodate it anymore without huge adjustments to the existing model of production.


A 16-episode season might water down the quality

Another issue of worry is how it would affect storytelling. More episodes do not necessarily translate to quality content. In recent years, the franchise has shifted towards shorter, leaner formats that maintain the tight pace and help viewers to fully immerse themselves in the high stakes situations. A 16-episode season might thin out the narrative, particularly if it is packed with filler episodes or irregular character appearances because of casting issues.

Fans have already criticized some seasons of The Walking Dead as dragging out plotlines or ignoring key characters. Recycling those problems into a potential new season would damage the franchise's reputation. With actors working on several spin-offs, it is more difficult to create a cohesive and meaningful story worthy of the show's history.


The future of The Walking Dead is fragmented by design

Ultimately, the world of The Walking Dead has become a series of character-driven tales, each of which is written for individual arcs and tones. This artistic choice, though providing flexibility in terms of storytelling, necessarily makes a more traditional ensemble season more difficult to achieve. The casting complications associated with a 16-episode comeback aren't an issue of unwillingness — it's the reality of the main players in the show no longer being where they once were, either physically or creatively.

Unless the spin-offs end or experience a long hiatus, it's not likely that the franchise can provide a full season without drastic compromises. Perhaps a reunion-like limited series could be an option, in line with what the franchise has been gravitating toward. For the time being, the 16-episode model is more nostalgic artifact than an available choice for the future.

Edited by Ayesha Mendonca