“Awesome performance” American Idol fans react to Slater Nalley’s top 8 performance of Bruce Springsteen’s Atlantic City 

As American Idol season 23 gets closer to selecting its Top 7, the competition gets more intense. On Monday, May 5, 2025, fans saw 18-year-old Slater Nalley earn his seat with a performance of Bruce Springsteen's "Atlantic City" that went viral on social media. Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, and Carrie Underwood chose the songs that the finalists will perform during a special "Judges' Song Contest" episode.

Bryan's choice for Nalley proved strategic, playing to the young performer's strengths and stage presence. Fans flocked to social media platforms immediately after the broadcast, praising Nalley's interpretation of the classic track. Many viewers noted his natural stage presence and vocal control, with several declaring him a frontrunner in the competition.

The enthusiastic reception highlights how Nalley has built a dedicated following throughout the season, with many viewers impressed by his ability to tackle diverse musical styles while maintaining his authentic performance style.

American Idol fans react to Slater Nalley’s performance

Despite the overwhelmingly positive response, fan reactions weren't entirely unanimous.

Most supporters praised Nalley's stage presence and vocal delivery, emphasizing his natural performance ability despite his young age. These fans positioned him as a potential winner, noting his consistency throughout the competition.

“Huge shoutout from California to New Jersey (and New York as well). What an awesome performance of Bruce @springsteen’s song “Atlantic City”, as done by Slater Nalley!” one fan commented on X.com

“Slater Nalley crushed it, he owns the stage and is a true performer. Only person id buy a concert ticket to see.” another fan said.

“Bruce juice!!! O yeah” another fan said.

“I’ve liked every single one of Slater’s performances but this has got to be my favorite from the Bruce Springsteen song to his vocal perfection all the way though” a fan wrote.

A smaller contingent expressed reservations about the song choice itself, though many still acknowledged his overall talent and previous strong performances. These viewers noted that while the song might not have been ideal, Nalley's technical execution remained impressive.

“That was an incredible performance by slater nalley, It was one of the best performances of the night this week during the judges song contest” a fan wrote.

“He’s a natural performer. He really connects with the audience. For 18, seems likes he’s been doing this for years. I like his style. He’s one that can tour. I can see him opening up for Luke or Carrie.” another fan posted.

“Wasn’t a fan of the song choice but based on his previous weeks, he’s been the most consistent this entire season. He deserves to go through.” a fan mused online.

“A great young man! Tons of talent!!” a fan declared.

“Slater for the win!!!” one fan commented.

“every week on american idol that john, slater, and thunderstorm make it through is a good week” a fan commented.

The debate extended to comparisons with other contestants, with some fans grouping Nalley with fellow competitors John Foster and Thunderstorm Artis as their favorite performers.

Luke Bryan picked the Springsteen number that won hearts

This episode of American Idol featured an innovative twist with judges competing against each other through song selections.

Luke Bryan, who chose Nalley's Springsteen number, correctly predicted the song would suit the contestant's style and energy. After the performance, Bryan expressed satisfaction with Nalley's interpretation, earning a point in the judges' competition.

Lionel Richie offered additional praise, highlighting Nalley's "amazing abilities" and even complimenting his fashion choice, a fringe shirt worn with confidence. Richie predicted Nalley would "go a long way" in the competition.

The American Idol judges' contest ended with Bryan and Richie tied at three points each, while Carrie Underwood earned two. This tie gave the male judges decision-making power for the evening's elimination.

Nalley's success places him among the American Idol Top 7 alongside Jamal Roberts, Breanna Nix, Mattie Pruitt, Gabby Samone, John Foster, and Thunderstorm Artis.

Josh King was eliminated after Bryan and Richie chose to save Mattie Pruitt when both contestants found themselves in jeopardy. The decision came after Nalley presented the final performance of the night.

As the competition advances, Nalley's consistent performances and growing fan base position him as a serious contender for the title. His ability to connect with audiences while tackling challenging material suggests he may have staying power beyond the competition.

The next episode of American Idol promises even more intense competition as the remaining seven contestants battle for spots in the finals, with Nalley now established as a performer to watch on the road to crowning this season's American Idol.

---

American Idol airs Sundays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and is available to stream the next day on Hulu.