Sullivan’s Crossing has always had a thing for playing with the emotions of their fans, but season 3 of the show brings about one of their most emotional storylines that has ever been done. At the end of season 2, Maggie Sullivan was seen expecting her first child, wanting to raise the baby alone.
But when a diner fire changed everything, her pregnancy took a turn. In season 3, fans finally get the answer, and it is revealed that Maggie does not have her baby anymore due to a miscarriage, and her journey forward is raw, heartfelt, and deeply human.
The emotional fallout after the diner fire in Sullivan’s Crossing
Season 2 of Sullivan’s Crossing wrapped on a cliffhanger with Sully's life hanging in the balance after a fire ripped through the diner, and so did Maggie's. As the new season opens, cues signal that something is wrong.
In one early scene, Maggie pauses while watching a boy drop his toy truck, her expression clouded with sadness. Later, she's seen folding tiny baby clothes in a quiet, heavy moment that speaks volumes without a single line of dialogue.
The truth is revealed in a flashback. On the night of the fire, Maggie was rushed to the hospital, where Cal, Edna, and Frank gently told her the devastating news - she had miscarried. The stress of that night had taken too much from her body.
The miscarriage itself happens off-screen, but the weight of it lingers. Maggie struggles to let Cal in, keeping her grief close to her chest. Even after the couple reconnects in episode 2, small, quiet moments show that her pain hasn't disappeared. As a fan, you feel the ache between them, making this one of Sullivan’s Crossing's most delicate and honest portrayals yet.
Morgan Kohan on portraying Maggie’s loss
For Morgan Kohan, playing out Maggie's grief in Sullivan's Crossing was more than just another storyline. Speaking to Good Housekeeping, she called it "a really important storyline to bring up" in season 3 of Sullivan’s Crossing. She explained;
"This topic is not talked about as much as it should be...It affects so many different people in many capacities — whether it's happened to you or someone you love. I was definitely nervous to portray it respectfully and in the right capacity to be honest and help people feel seen."
Kohan also credited her co-star Chad Michael Murray and the entire crew for the sensitivity they brought to filming such intense scenes.
She said;
"We have such a wonderful cast and crew who are so supportive and respectful during scenes like this...As Maggie is held in a different way, I feel very held by Chad and everyone on set... I felt very allowed to just go full in on it."
The relationship between Maggie and Cal is put to the test by this tragedy, but it also shows their resilience and love that they share for each other. One of the season's most soft moments comes from when they plant a tree together in the baby's memory, which is an act of remembering and loving, an act that feels heartbreaking but something that also helps them both heal.
Season 3 of Sullivan’s Crossing continues to explore how the two of them make their way out through challenges, making this season a test of their relationship.
In Sullivan's Crossing, Maggie, as a character in season 3, is a reminder that healing is not linear. She may have lost her baby, but her story is about more than the loss she faced, and it's about love, grief, remembering, and the people who hold you up when you can't stand on your own.
For fans of Sullivan’s Crossing, it's an arc that proves the show's power lies not just in its drama, but in its heart.
Stay tuned to Soapcentral for more.