Enjoyed watching All Her Fault on Peacock? Watch these 5 mystery thrillers next and you won't regret it

If you finished watching All Her Fault on Peacock, then you must be reeling from the nail-biting mystery involving Milo and his mother's quest to find him. The story is packed with thrills right from the beginning and many viewers must now be craving for more such stories.

And if you're thinking the same, then you're at the right place! The latest TV series follows the story from Andrea Mara’s bestselling novel, and pulls viewers into a parent’s worst nightmare: learning that your kid is missing and almost no one knows about his disappearance at all.

This is exactly what All Her Fault is about: mixing secrets, betrayal, and moral dilemmas that keep you second-guessing everyone until the very end. Another reason to watch the series is that it has some of the most recognized actors like Sarah Snook, Dakota Fanning, Jake Lacy, Abby Elliot, and more.

Find more such shows below.

5 mystery thrillers to watch if you enjoyed All Her Fault on Peacock

Mystery thrillers are what drama lovers enjoy the most, and All Her Fault is the latest TV series on Peacock that offers a great story. And if you enjoyed the thriller, here are other shows that will give you the same experience:

1) Lady in the Lake (2024)

Lady in the Lake (Image via Prime Video)

Plot: The show, which is set in 1960s Baltimore, begins with a young girl going missing during a parade and follows the lives of two women as secrets, injustice, and crime collide: Maddie Schwartz, a housewife who becomes a journalist, and Cleo Johnson, a mother who tries to support her family.

Cast: Natalie Portman stars as Maddie Schwartz; Moses Ingram plays Cleo Johnson and more talented stars appear in the show.

Where to watch: This TV series is available on Prime Video.

Also Read: Where was All Her Fault filmed? Revisiting key filming locations of the latest mystery thriller

2) Sugar (2024)

Sugar features Colin Farrell (Image via Apple TV+ Press)

Plot: Sugar is a mystery thriller TV series that focuses on Detective John Sugar investigating the disappearance of Olivia, the granddaughter of a powerful film producer. As he starts the quest, a web of lies and unexpected truths emerges. What makes this similar to All Her Fault is that the protagonist starts unraveling hidden secrets.

Cast: Colin Farrell plays John Sugar and is joined by other actors like Sydney Chandler, Amy Ryan and more.

Where to watch: Sugar can be streamed on Apple TV+.

3) The Survivors (2025)

The Survivors TV series (Image via Netflix)

Plot: The Survivors is a 2025 TV series about a family returning to their home in Evelyn Bay (Tasmania) where a tragic incident happened 15 years ago: two drowned and a young girl disappeared. When a new body is found, many of the town’s secrets begin to surface.

Cast: Charlie Vickers plays Kieran Elliot; Yerin Ha plays his partner Mia Chang along with other cast members.

Where to watch: The Survivors is on Netflix.

Also Read: Love K-dramas? These 5 Filipino shows will give you the same feels

4) Missing You (2025)

Plot: Another mystery thriller that you must watch after enjoying All Her Fault is Missing You, which is about Detective Kat Donovan, whose fiancé vanished 11 years ago. When she unexpectedly sees him on a dating app, she is pulled back into unresolved secrets, missing-person investigations, and past trauma.

Cast: Rosalind Eleazar as Kat Donovan; Richard Armitage, among others.

Where to watch: Missing You is on Netflix

5) Six Four (2023)

Six Four TV series (Image via Prime Video)

Plot: Six Four is a mystery thriller in which a teenage daughter goes missing, just like Milo did in All Her Fault. The girl's father happens to be a detective, and when he starts finding out about his daughter's disappearance, corruption and mysteries unfold.

Cast: Kevin McKidd as Chris O’Neill; Vinette Robinson as Michelle O’Neill; Alex Ferns and others.

Where to watch: The series is on Prime Video.