How Task Episode 1 perfectly portrays nuances of both sides of the law 

Task ( Image via YouTube / HBO Max )
Task ( Image via YouTube / HBO Max )

Task Episode 1 immediately makes it very clear that it is no ordinary crime drama, but a work about humanity on both sides of the law! The pilot, Crossings, draws a line between two men, FBI agent Tom Brandis, whose personal tragedy plagues him and takes a toll on him, and garbage collector Robbie Prendergrast, whose secret second job is the cause of tension. Task puts crime and justice in the same glass by portraying the lives of both men in living color.

The best part of Task Episode 1 is that it does not demonize or glamorize either of the worlds! Instead, it makes desperation, survival, and sorrow too human. Tom misses his wife when he keeps serving in law enforcement, and Robbie will do anything to feed his children.

The series creates a balance of a story by compelling the audience to sit down with both sides of the argument, the one who upholds the law and the one who disobeys without providing any easy solutions.


Character duality center stage in Task Episode 1

youtube-cover

What is interesting about Task, perhaps, is the manner in which it presents Tom and Robbie as polar opposites. Tom, an ex-priest who has become a murder-stopper, is played by Mark Ruffalo, whose grief marked the conclusion of his livelihood in religion. Everything, even taking care of a garden, is imbued with his suffering, as well as an investigative trend.

Robbie, played by Tom Pelphrey, is also a subtle character; he is not a criminal genius but a father who will go to any extent to feed his children. They are both subtle acts, and Task Episode 1 makes the most of its duration by demonstrating the complexity of the role.

It is this absence of digression that makes the story plausible. The idealistic, chivalrous is not the law, as Tom. Task allows people to perceive that there is a bad man, one who tries to redeem himself by his job, and another who is trying to hold on to righteousness, but he is also a criminal.


A stunning loss that sets the tone

At the very outset, Task makes it clear that there is nothing and there is no one safe. It is the first robbery that ends up being fatal, with the brutal murder of Peaches, the character of Owen Teague, who has been presented in a humorous and likable manner. It is not only a surprise, but it is a statement.

According to AOL.com, the reason behind the surprise murder has been elaborated by the Director Brad Ingelsby, who has stated that the murder was used to emphasize the vulnerability of all lives in this place. He said,

"It lets an audience know that everything is on the table. So quickly they kill off a character we’ve come to like? Guess who else is on the chopping block? That was a decision we made early on. Owen brings so much to that character in such a short amount of time. It sets up the stakes of the piece. It helps to introduce this idea to the audience that everything is on the table in a show like this."

In Task, there is no superiority between the criminal actors and the law enforcers, and the stakes are always high physically.

This introduction predetermines the remainder of the series. By getting rid of what appears to be one of the central characters early in the series, Task is able to create a clear understanding that it would not follow the old-fashioned crime-drama format. Rather, it focuses on realism, chance, and cold-blooded arbitrariness of violence.


How Crime is made mundane

Task never glamorizes crime, but it doesn't demonize crime as well. Robbie's insistence on continuing to steal from houses is brought out as a desperate measure and not as an evil plot. His behavior is even immoral, but the show does a great job of making him a father figure before he is a thief.

Most revealing is when Robbie saves Sam, a boy who catches him breaking the house, rather than hurting him. This is what leaves audiences guessing: villain or hero? Task achieves this here. In leaving room for Robbie's humanity to creep into his criminality, it never makes it easy for the audience's moral decision. The character is human, flawed, and conflicted.


Law enforcement through fragility

youtube-cover

Tom's FBI agent is no less complicated. Task Episode 1 shows him not as a formidable figure of power but as a bereaved man trying to fill what loss has removed. His priestly background taps into his behavior, moments of introspection, remorse, and the overwhelming power of moral responsibility. But policing demands that he also be tough, forthright, and unyielding.

This irony, mourning man Tom and state agent Tom, is proof that even law enforcers are not immune to internal contradiction. Task perceives law enforcement as a human institution and not as an ideal agency.


Visual and regional authenticity

The assignment's realism is geographically based. Set in Philadelphia blue-collar suburbs, the episode uses deliberately DelCo neighborhoods, Ridley Creek State Park, and Downingtown streets. All of these, admittedly, help to add grime and realism to a crime and law enforcement tale fighting within the daily lives. The increased immersion comes from the cast struggling to get their tongues around the local "DelCo" accent.

From the garbage routes of Robbie to the tomato plot of Tom, it's all in the details. Task Episode 1's every shot is guided by actual neighborhoods and actual issues, keeping the story pegged to what actually happens rather than what doesn't happen.


Parallels and symmetry

The most sophisticated storytelling choice made in Task Episode 1 is its symmetry. Tom and Robbie's lives are constructed in reflected rhythms, housebreaking and horticulture, mask-wearing and bird-keeping. The reflected scenes advise the spectator that the two men are behaving according to the same imperatives: loss, responsibility, and need.

By juxtaposing their lives, Task poses an uncomfortable question: what constitutes law and order and crime, because both are motivated by human weakness? This figural convention keeps the viewer in suspense about where it stands.


Why Episode 1 sticks

What makes Task Episode 1 work is that it absolutely refuses to offer us simple truths. Rather than showing law as inherently good and crime as inherently evil, it always shows them both to be reactions to the brutality of life. Tom is the vulnerability behind authority, and Robbie is the flesh behind crime. Neither can be excused, but neither is revered.

This is not the conventional balance in crime dramas. Task wallows in complexity, a tale where living, mourning, and losing hold sway more than simple dichotomies of "good" and "bad."


Hence, Task Episode 1 is not a reductionist law and crime story, of individuals being compelled to make impossible choices. By granting equal narrative capital to Tom and Robbie, the series is not taking sides. It depicts sadness, despair, and humanity on either side of the law, and places the action in real locations and lived-in texture.

And lastly, Task prevails and perishes in understatement. It shows us law enforcement not as untouchable heroes but as fragile humans, and criminals not as faceless villains but as conflicted fathers. And it is that contradiction that Task Episode 1 comes to the dirty, ugly world of justice and survival, where everyone is vulnerable.

Also read: Task release schedule: When do new episodes of the Mark Ruffalo series drop on HBO?

Edited by Anjali Singh