I believe Love Island USA star Ace is a red flag and Amaya deserves better

It’s only been a few episodes into Love Island USA Season 7, and I think Ace Greene is already raising eyebrows, and not necessarily in a good way. His rocky connection with Amaya Espinal has become a central storyline, and fans are torn. Some think there’s more to Ace than meets the eye. Others wonder if Amaya’s caught in a loop of miscommunication and emotional whiplash. According to me, their dynamic is stirring the pot and driving the conversation.

The tension really picked up in Episode 7 when Amaya jokingly called Ace “babe,” and he didn’t take it well.

"Even 'babe' is, like, a lot for me too," he told her.

That one moment set off a chain of events—awkward convos, mixed signals, and emotional distance — that’s left viewers, including me, wondering whether Ace is in this for real or just playing it cool to stay safe in the villa. Either way, it’s given Love Island USA its first proper reality check of the season.

---

Love Island USA star Ace’s mixed signals aren’t charming anymore

I believe Ace’s behavior is walking a thin line between mysterious and manipulative. From pulling Amaya in with soft-spoken chats to pulling away when things get too emotional, he’s keeping her on a tightrope. It’s giving a red flag, and fans are picking up on it.

Things got even more complicated when Amaya caught Chelley crying and tried to support her. That moment led to a tense exchange, but rather than stepping in maturely, Ace distanced himself from both women. Instead of owning his role, he’s been sliding into the background.

In the context of Love Island USA, where communication is everything, Ace’s hot-and-cold approach is, in my opinion, starting to wear thin. Viewers aren’t buying the nice guy act anymore.

---

Amaya’s emotional labor shouldn’t be ignored

Let’s talk about Amaya. Since Day 1 on Love Island USA, she’s been emotionally open, supportive, and all-in with Ace. According to me, she’s not just navigating her own feelings but also trying to handle Ace’s discomfort around labels and vulnerability. That’s a lot of weight to carry.

In a moment that stood out, Amaya told Ace,

"I usually make up a nickname for them, like my own personal nickname or babe."

That simple, sweet line somehow snowballed into a relationship crisis. Instead of laughing it off or clarifying his boundaries, Ace turned it into a wall between them. I think it’s the kind of emotional reaction that shows he might not be ready for the kind of partnership Amaya’s offering.

As Love Island USA keeps throwing these two together, Amaya continues to show emotional maturity. She deserves someone who meets her halfway, not someone who’s halfway out the door the moment things get too real.

---

Is Ace playing the game or just confused?

A recurring question in the villa, and among fans, is whether Ace is genuinely confused or just playing the game. When he said it,

“I don’t like talking about feelings all the time,”

it struck a chord. Is that emotional unavailability or a strategy to dodge deep connections?

Some Islanders suspect Ace is coasting. He hasn’t shown much initiative when it comes to deepening the relationship with Amaya. Instead, he seems to thrive on keeping things vague, keeping his options open just enough to stay safe. It’s a common survival tactic on Love Island USA, but it often backfires.

Whether it’s intentional or not, Ace’s behavior has pushed Amaya into a defensive position. She’s left wondering where she stands while Ace acts like everything’s chill. In my opinion, the lack of clarity is becoming its own form of manipulation.

---

Chelley's drama makes things murkier

Love Island USA Episode 8 also saw a dramatic shift when Chelley entered the conversation, and emotions ran high. Chelley’s tearful moment put Amaya in an awkward position, one that Ace did little to ease. Instead of addressing what happened directly, Ace chose silence.

While Chelley didn’t directly accuse Amaya of anything, the tension in the air was obvious. Yet again, Ace sat on the sidelines. A partner who truly cared would have stepped in to clear things up. But Ace left both women hanging.

For Love Island USA fans, this moment confirmed their suspicions: Ace might not be the villain, but he’s not exactly innocent either. In my view, silence in moments like this speaks volumes.

---

Fans are already taking sides

It’s not just happening in the Love Island USA villa; viewers have turned their couches into jury boxes. On platforms like Instagram and Twitter, Love Island USA fans are dissecting every Ace and Amaya interaction.

"He comes across so cocky I don’t even know why he’s on the show. If he wants to be a slow burn and not be called babe then he needs to go to the grocery store and find some little old lady to date him." One user commented

"Chelley and amaya both needa avoid ace he reeks of problems and hes so jealous of huda and jere." another added

While that might sound harsh, it reflects a growing sentiment among Love Island USA watchers. I think they’re not here for emotional aloofness disguised as depth. And they’re especially not here for women doing all the emotional heavy lifting while the guys float by on charm and ambiguity.

The public’s pulse is clear: Amaya is coming across as genuine and thoughtful, while Ace’s vibe feels calculated. It’s not the kind of love story I, or many Love Island USA fans, want to root for.

---

In conclusion, I think if Ace wants to make this work, he’ll need to start being real, not just retreating when things get intense. As for Amaya, I genuinely hope she recognizes her worth and stops chasing clarity from someone who refuses to give it.

Whatever unfolds, one thing is clear: this situationship has been a reality check not just for the Islanders, but for everyone watching. And I think it’s made Love Island USA must-watch TV once again.

Also Read: Fact Check: Did Love Island USA star Ace have a problem with Amaya calling him “babe”?