It: Welcome to Derry might just be the perfect replacement for Stranger Things - Here’s why we think so

It: Welcome to Derry ( Image via YouTube / HBO Max )
It: Welcome to Derry ( Image via YouTube / HBO Max )

What if Hawkins had a dark counterpart? What if the reminiscence of Stranger Things met the horror world of Stephen King? It: Welcome to Derry might be that ideal middle ground, a show with the same small-town mystery and emotional friendship but replacing Demogorgons with something far worse.

Indeed, It: Welcome to Derry might be the best successor to Stranger Things, not because it copies the latter but because it enlarges the very sentiments that made it a worldwide hit.

The prequel on HBO Max during the 1960s will take you through the twisted beginnings of Pennywise and the cursed town of Derry, Maine. Although the horror aspect takes over the adventure, the theme remains the same.

Kids' innocence is the battleground in both series, and small-town life is the means to reveal the fear that is common to all. However, It: Welcome to Derry is the braver one to take the path that Stranger Things never completely walked, right into the core of fear and suffering!


It: Welcome to Derry and Stranger Things:

Structural similarities: Childhood vs. the unknown

youtube-cover

Stories of It: Welcome to Derry and Stranger Things, at their most profound, share a common ground of young people battling with their understanding of the world. It: Welcome to Derry purposely flips the Stranger Things story and presents a tale where kids are not the brave heroes in a coming-of-age adventure but victims of an evil that has been around for generations and that of small-town repression.

The year 1962 in Derry and the aura of Hawkins, marked by children deceiving the adults, gradual fear creeping in, and uneasy silence, are very similar to each other. On one hand, Stranger Things incorporates some of the 80s allure through nostalgia; on the other, It: Welcome to Derry has a grave and rational portrayal, particularly of the Cold War anxieties, the race relations, and the social isolation.

Hence, it is right to conclude that Derry is the place where Hawkins' past evil is not only camouflaged but is also an integral part of everyday life.


Nostalgic setting: From 1980s pop to 1960s unease

Stranger Things is mainly a nostalgic 1980s-set television show with a very colorful presentation of that time through the mall scenes, the synthesizer music, and the D&D campaigns. On the contrary, It: Welcome to Derry does not bring in the warmth of the pop culture but rather the discomfort of history.

The creative team of Andy and Barbara Muschietti used the backdrop of the 1960s for their art to introduce post-war anxieties, racism, and political turmoil into the storyline, which are not very common topics in the supernatural genre.

It: Welcome to Derry is not resorting to the use of callbacks or retro references; instead, the era itself is employed in a way that it becomes a mirror, showing how social fear gives birth to literal horror. And this transition of nostalgia from sentimental to disturbing undoubtedly makes the series more adult and reflective.

In a sense, Derry is very much like Hawkins minus its neon comfort, revealing the psychological undercut that is raw and unrestrained beneath the nostalgia that Stranger Things fans have always loved.


Horror roots: Fear that cuts deeper

youtube-cover

Stranger Things is a blend of science fiction, fantasy, and horror, while It: Welcome to Derry firmly stands in the horror realm. It is based on Stephen King’s works, particularly the idea of fear as a living creature.

It: Welcome to Derry reveals monsters not as symbols but as manifestations where, alongside silence, evil's denial and community support are places where it thrives. Consequently, this gets even more disturbing than the Upside Down, as it is terribly human.

If Stranger Things takes you back to the days of playing with friends, it’s the opposite with it, as it makes you reconsider what those moments were concealing all the time.


Dual storylines: Childhood and adulthood intertwined

Childhood experiences are the main factor in both productions, while adults are primarily the ones who decide how deep or shallow those arcs are. The HBO series leans more heavily on the duality of characters' development.

In contrast to Stranger Things, which mostly shows its characters growing up at the same time, this prequel has the story of younger and older generations overlapping to demonstrate how Pennywise never completely goes away. This kind of narrative adds an emotional dimension to the series that goes beyond mere terror.

It is not only about living through evil, but also about the process of being changed by evil and silence flourishing it.


Audience fit: For the brave and the curious

It: Welcome to Derry is a suggested film for those viewers who enjoyed the mystery-driven storytelling of Stranger Things but are looking for something darker. Inverse observes that although the series does not feature the fanciful charm of Hawkins’ kids, it still leads through cinematic tension, strong ensemble casts, and natural emotional realism.

It is a production that considers the viewers’ brainpower; it relies less on startling scenes and more on the question of what happens when horror becomes the norm. If Stranger Things was about battling the monsters outside, It: Welcome to Derry is about fighting the ones inside.


Behind the scenes: Expanding King’s universe

According to reports from Entertainment Weekly and Koimoi, the new series of IT is set to take viewers on a journey beyond the original book and films. The narrative style adopted by Andy Muschietti, the master of the It movies, is the same, but he is also able to disclose a deeper psychological understanding of Pennywise's origins.

The saga not only unveils the town's dark past but also indicates Derry as a terrible monster that lives on and is deeply feared, a classic and still fascinating thought for many of Stephen King’s readers.

Such creative integrity between the films allows It: Welcome to Derry to be seen as a separate creation that is still interconnected with the bigger It cosmos and an heir in terms of both mood and heritage.


Ultimately, It: Welcome to Derry, even though it may not be able to charm the audience like Stranger Things did, does not have to. It is a strong character in its own, one that adds more to what Stranger Things started: an innocent, feared, and dark human need to comprehend evil and darkness through the already mentioned aspects.

Thus, It: Welcome to Derry could actually be said to be a perfect substitute for Stranger Things, not in the sense of being the same, but in being a reason to remember why we fell for the tales in the beginning, the excitement of confronting the unseen, and the realization that at times, the most frightening creatures are the ones that are not from a different universe at all.

Also read: IT: Welcome to Derry Episode 2 - Release date news, time, streaming details, cast, and more

Edited by Zainab Shaikh