“On FIRE tonight” — America’s Got Talent fans react to Ariana Madix’s ex, Tom Sandoval’s audition

Tom Sandoval and the Most Extras on America
Tom Sandoval and the Most Extras on America's Got Talent | Image via Instagram/ @tomsandoval1

Something electrifying was obviously expected as soon as Tom Sandoval took the stage on America's Got Talent. With a guitar in hand, the former Vanderpump Rules star ventured out into the spotlight to prove to the world that he is a true musician who is more than the controversy that rocked his life.

Tom Sandoval & The Most Extras, his group, started things off with an energetic performance of A-ha’s Take On Me. Switching the narrative up and letting his music speak for itself, he openly copped to his much-publicized 2023 "Scandoval" cheating scandal. The four judges’ reactions ranged from compliments regarding his inescapable stage presence to remarks about his singing, but they all expressed awareness of his absurd commitment to perform.

Viewers soon took to X (previously known as Twitter) to share their reaction to Tom’s performance. Some were skeptical, while many marveled at his charm and redemption story. What happens next, well, that remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Tom’s audition made a lot of noise, both good and bad.

An admirer of America's Got Talent shared: "Tom Sandoval & The Next Extras were on FIRE tonight!!! Not only they will go all the way to the Finale in September, but also their rendition of A-ha's 'Take on Me' will make it to the Billboard Hot 100 Charts!!! WOW!!! #AGT."
Another tweet read: "Tom Sandoval & The Next Extras SHOULD have got the #GoldenBuzzer because it was the best act in Week 5 of the auditions. #AGT."
"I don't watch Vanderpump Rules but Tom and the Most Extras were good #AGT," a fan wrote.

Other fans of America's Got Talent, however, shared different opinions.

A viewer posted: "I don’t care who the hell Tom Sandoval is, his act on #AGT wasn’t good. He has the 'looks,' but his voice isn’t great & the act wasn’t good. Who agrees? Clearly he’s a SOME1 since they’re making a big deal about him & want everyone to like the act… but pass. #AmericasGotTalent."
"Tom Sandoval is a complete IDIOT Evil & no one will vote for you Mr. Cheater. We hated you on PumpRules & we still hate you. #AGT," an X user commented.

“You gave me happy vibes” — America's Got Talent judge Mel B’s comments on Tom Sandoval’s audition

After Tom Sandoval & The Most Extras' spirited America's Got Talent Season 20 performance, Mel B wasn't holding back while praising them. When the music stopped, she was the first judge to stand, demonstrating the festive mood they created on stage.

"You made me smile. You gave me happy vibes … you all look like you were fully enjoying yourselves."

That response was not unexpected. Mel B has expressed her admiration for the band's genuineness, particularly their decision to accept their role as a cover band. Simon Cowell's frank criticism of the singing was counterbalanced by her encouragement, demonstrating that Sandoval's attempt at a resurrection was more than simply drama and had real entertainment value.


You can watch all the episodes of America's Got Talent on NBC.

Edited by Sarah Nazamuddin Harniswala