'%20x='0'%20y='0'%20height='100%25'%20width='100%25'%20%0A%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20xlink%3Ahref=''%3E%3C/image%3E%3C/svg%3E)
The Beast in Me Season 2 feels like the one sequel that just has to exist, mainly because the first season left us with way more questions than answers. If the show ever continues, these big mysteries could finally get the spotlight.
We know Aggie survived the chaos around Nile, we know she finished her book, but the real story behind her past and the shadows she carries is still unexplored. And honestly, that alone makes The Beast in Me Season 2 feel impossible to skip.
5 burning questions that The Beast in Me Season 2 needs to answer
1. What really went down between Aggie and her dad?
The biggest mystery The Beast in Me Season 2 needs to clear up is the weird, messy situation between Aggie and her dad. The show sprinkled little clues about him, almost like a trail of crumbs.
We know he was arrested when Aggie was a kid. We know he didn’t love the way she wrote about him later in her memoir. But the drama between them feels deeper than just one book and one bad childhood. If Season 2 happens, it could finally show us what their bond used to be like. Maybe they were close once. Maybe he was the reason Aggie grew up carrying all that darkness inside her.
Flashbacks could actually bring the puzzle together. And since Aggie keeps running from the parts of herself she doesn’t like, a new crime could force her to face him again. This question alone could fill a whole season, and honestly, fans deserve those answers.
2. How far will Aggie go now that Nile is gone?
One thing the finale made super clear is that Nile didn’t just mess with Aggie’s life. He kind of unlocked something inside her. She always tried to bury the darker parts of herself, but being around him pulled those pieces right to the surface.
The Beast in Me Season 2 could finally show if Aggie is willing to look that truth in the eye or if she keeps pretending she is totally fine. Aggie’s inner world is literally one big storm she pretends is sunshine. Nile noticed her darkness before she did and even pushed her to tap into it while they were circling each other. Now that Nile is dead, Aggie has no one to mirror that side of her.
The Beast in Me Season 2 could force her to deal with the thing she hates most. Maybe another case drags her in. Maybe she crosses a line she never thought she’d cross. The show hinted at her “bloodlust,” but never actually explored it. Season 2 can finally dive into that scary place.
3. Will Shelley stay in Aggie’s life or drift away for good?
If we get The Beast in Me Season 2, Aggie’s relationship with Shelley seriously needs attention. Shelley has always been this steady presence, even though their marriage ended.
She is the kind of character who says little but sees everything. Based on Season 1, she could either be Aggie’s anchor or the person who gets pushed away when Aggie spirals deeper into her own world.
Aggie going through new trauma, mixed with the weight of Nile’s crimes, could make Shelley step in more. Or it could finally break whatever connection is left between them. Shelley isn’t just an ex. She’s a reminder of who Aggie used to be before all the chaos.
Season 2 could hugely test that bond, especially if Aggie’s secrets start catching up to her. Watching their dynamic shift again would be one of the most interesting parts of the story.
4. Could Nina come back with a bigger storyline?
Nina was such a quiet force in the first chapter. She didn’t scream or throw things or break down. She paid attention. And in the end, she exposed Nile. If The Beast in Me Season 2 ever happens, Nina could return with a story that digs into how she moves forward after everything. She has a child now. She also carries the trauma of discovering her husband was a murderer.
There is so much to explore here. Maybe Nina tries to rebuild her life and crosses paths with Aggie again. Maybe she becomes a key voice in how the world views Nile after everything came out. She could even bring new information that pulls Aggie into a fresh mystery. Nina’s character has so much unused potential that Season 2 could easily expand into her world in a bigger way.
5. What new crime will drag Aggie back into danger?
Every good thriller needs that spark that pulls the lead back into the mess, and The Beast in Me Season 2 would definitely need a crime that hits close to home. Something that ties her past, her present, and her inner chaos together.
The first season already showed how fast Aggie gets tangled up in danger. Now the question is whether she jumps in willingly or gets dragged in again without noticing.
The show hinted that Aggie’s darkness isn’t going away. So maybe Season 2 gives her a mystery that forces her to face the side of herself she keeps pretending doesn’t exist. And this time, Nile won’t be around to tell her who she is. She will have to figure that out on her own.
The Beast in Me Season 2 isn’t just something fans want. It feels like the only way to finish the emotional maze that the first chapter started. Aggie’s past, her shifting relationships and the darker parts of her personality all still need answers.
If Netflix ever brings it back, the next chapter could unravel everything the finale only teased and finally show who Aggie becomes when the truth catches up to her.
Trending
Stay tuned to Soap Central for more.
Reply
