The Boys Showrunner talks about the complex character of Billy Butcher in Season 5

Ever since its debut in 2019, The Boys has never been your average superhero series. Instead of capes and clean-cut morals, it gave us chaos, corporate greed, and deeply flawed characters wrapped in blood and satire. It flipped the superhero genre on its head and forced us to question what absolute power really looks like. Now, as the fifth and final season approaches, showrunner Eric Kripke is shedding light on the complicated path ahead for Billy Butcher, one of the show’s most morally ambiguous and emotionally layered characters.

While fans are gearing up for epic showdowns and long-awaited resolutions, Kripke is focusing on something deeper: the psychological toll that years of loss, revenge, and guilt have taken on Butcher. The final season won’t just be about explosions and battles, it’s about what happens when a man runs out of reasons to keep fighting, yet fights anyway.

---

A superhero story turned on its head

The Boys isn’t just another comic book adaptation, it’s a full-blown takedown of everything we’ve come to expect from superhero stories. Created by Garth Ennis and Darick Robertson and published between 2006 and 2012, the comic was unapologetically wild, dark, and brutally honest. It didn’t just cross the line, it stomped all over it to show how dangerous unchecked power can be, especially when dressed in a shiny, heroic image.

The TV version keeps that rebellious spirit alive but takes a more grounded approach. It tones down some of the over-the-top chaos from the comics and leans into character depth and real-world echoes. Rather than shocking for the sake of it, the show uses its outrageous world to explore deeply human questions about morality, loyalty, and the corrosive effects of power.

Set in a world where superheroes, or "Supes", are managed by a powerful corporation called Vought, the story centers on a ragtag group of vigilantes led by Billy Butcher (played by Karl Urban). Their goal? Take down corrupt Supes, especially Homelander (Antony Starr), the most terrifying of them all, a twisted Superman archetype with a god complex.

---

Billy Butcher’s descent into darkness

In an interview with Collider, Eric Kripke explained that Season 5 will put Butcher in a place he's never been before, completely out of time and options. After years of heartbreak and morally gray decisions, Butcher now sees Ryan, the son of his late wife Becca and Homelander, as lost to the dark side. That belief pushes him toward one last, desperate measure: using a deadly virus to wipe out all Supes, even if it means destroying himself in the process.

Kripke paints Butcher as a man driven by a warped sense of justice, someone who truly believes he’s saving the world even as he burns it down. He’s not the hero, not really, but he’s not the villain either. He walks the in-between path, stuck in a moral gray zone, and that’s exactly what makes him one of the show’s most compelling figures.

---

Butcher and Homelander: two sides of the same coin

One of Kripke’s most intriguing insights is the idea that Butcher and Homelander are two sides of the same coin. Both are shaped by trauma, both are desperate to leave behind a legacy, and both are capable of extreme violence. The line between them is far thinner than it appears.

It’s a dynamic reminiscent of the Batman-Joker relationship. Like those iconic rivals, Butcher and Homelander are locked in a psychological battle as much as a physical one. Where Batman clings to a moral code and Joker wants to shatter it, Butcher and Homelander blur those lines entirely. They’re not trying to prove who’s right, they’re just trying to survive what they’ve become.

---

The return of Soldier Boy and what remains at stake

Season 5 will also bring back Soldier Boy (Jensen Ackles), first introduced in Season 3 as a twisted version of Captain America, patriotic on the outside, toxic to the core. This time, he returns with one goal: to kill Butcher. That alone raises the stakes considerably.

But according to Kripke, Soldier Boy’s return isn’t just for the fireworks. His presence forces Butcher and others to confront their past and the generational trauma that shaped their world. Soldier Boy is a symbol of everything that is broken in the system, and his reappearance is bound to shake up alliances and trigger long-overdue reckonings.

---

A critical hit with a loyal fanbase

The Boys has remained one of Prime Video’s biggest hits, with critics praising its sharp writing, fearless performances, and biting social commentary. And its success isn’t just hype, it’s backed by both numbers and genuine buzz. The show currently holds an impressive 93% score on Rotten Tomatoes and keeps sparking conversation with each new season. A huge part of that acclaim goes to Antony Starr, whose chilling performance as Homelander has made him one of the most unforgettable and unsettling villains on modern television.

Every season pulls in massive viewership, and the online chatter only adds fuel to the fire. From viral memes to wild fan theories, The Boys has found a way to stay relevant and surprising. It’s more than just a hit series, it’s a full-blown cultural moment.

---

A final chapter worth watching

As Kripke wraps up this wild ride, fans can expect more than just spectacle. The heart of The Boys has always been its messy, complicated characters, and none more so than Billy Butcher. Whether he finds redemption or goes down swinging, one thing’s for sure: he’ll leave a mark. And if Kripke delivers on his vision, Butcher’s final moments might just become some of the most unforgettable in modern TV history.