The most panned Gilmore Girls Episode actually explained Rory’s revival mess – Fans just didn’t realize it

Gilmore Girls has had its highs and lows, but nothing comes close to the lows with the show's lowest rated episode. Strangely enough, this very episode ends up unlocking the reason behind Rory's frustrating spiral in the Netflix revival.

Most fans were too focused on Lorelai's wedding drama with Christopher to even notice the happenings of the episode and that is Rory's quiet unraveling.

Gilmore Girls Season 7's "French Twist" might not be a fan favorite, but it clearly hinted at the internal chaos that would later define the youngest Gilmore's revival arc.

---

Rory's breakdown in Gilmore Girls Season 7's “French Twist” wasn’t just filler — it was the real beginning of her downfall

Though "French Twist" often gets skipped during rewatches because of Lorelai and Christopher's sudden wedding, Rory's subplot in this Gilmore Girls episode quietly lays down one of the roots of her collapse.

While Lorelai is off making decisions that feel out of character, Rory heads home with her Yale friends Lucy and Olivia.

What starts off lighthearted quickly shifts when Rory, overwhelmed by the reality of finishing college, finally breaks down. Her cries here aren't about hair dye, rather it's her first moment of true uncertainty, of the unknown.

For a character who always excelled when it came to structure, especially during the earlier seasons of Gilmore Girls, now suddenly facing a future without clear direction shakes her. She's no longer editor of the Yale Daily News, graduation is near, and there's no next step to be walked on.

Rory's confession to her friends shows that she's painfully aware of how lost she feels. It's a small moment, but an important one. In that quiet panic lies the seed of what we later see in A Year in the Life and that is a version of Rory who is still very much unsure, still drifting, and still trying to figure it all out.

This moment in Gilmore Girls also shows Rory coming to terms with her fears for the first time instead of hiding behind accomplishments or her usual perfectionism. It's one of the most emotionally honest points in her story.

---

The revival didn’t derail Rory’s story because “French Twist” already showed she was stuck

Many fans were disappointed when Rory's revival arc painted her as lost and 'unlike her character'. She bounced between career hopes, had a boyfriend whose name she could not remember, stayed entangled with Logan, and ended up pregnant without any clear sense of where her life was headed. But this wasn't a sudden fall.

Gilmore Girls had already shown, years before, that Rory had begun to struggle long before adulthood hit her and maybe even before Season 7.

Rory stealing a yacht in Season 5, Rory having an affair with Dean in Season 4, Rory stringing Dean along when she really wanted to be with Jess in Season 2 & 3...all of these show that the signs of her character going downhill were already present in the scripts.

In Season 7 we finally get to see glimpses of Rory's deep discomfort with ambiguity and herself. Her breakdown is more than just college stress. It reflects a lack of goals, of urgency, and of inner drive to move forward.

By the time A Year in the Life picks up, she's still stuck in the same loop where she's still on the hunt for looking a direction she never truly found. It's not laziness, it's a continuation of a character who thrived only when the next step was clear. Once that map disappeared, she was lost.

The revival didn't invent Rory's poor decisions. Her affair with Dean and now Logan along with her failing career all point back to this inner confusion.

Season 7 simply highlighted her inability to make hard choices, to act with clarity, or even to accept that she needed a new plan. She doesn't learn from her missteps. Not while she was at Chilton, not while she was at Yale, and certainly not in her 30s.

What fans saw as a failure in the revival was actually just Rory's fears finally catching up with her head-on.

---

"French Twist" might be the most hated Gilmore Girls episode, but it captured something that fans overlooked for years.

Rory's downfall didn't start in the Netflix revival. It started right there in season 7, or perhaps even before, when she finally realized the road ahead wasn't marked and wasn't easy.

The real twist is that it was right there all along, but nobody was watching closely enough.

Also read: Why the hate for Dean Forester needs to stop—A Gilmore Girls rethink

---

Stay tuned to Soapcentral for more news and updates on TV shows, films, daily soaps, pop culture and more.