Did The Young and the Restless' Audra have an affair with Sienna's husband Mitch?

Zuleyka Silver as Audra Charles on The Young and the Restless | Image: CBS
Zuleyka Silver as Audra Charles on The Young and the Restless | Image: CBS

On The Young and the Restless, so much of Audra's storyline is shrouded in mystery. We know she and Holden are keeping a huge secret about something that happened when they lived in Los Angeles. But with Audra, there's always the possibility that she could be keeping two secrets.

Sienna Bacall doesn't like her. We've been told that Sienna is married to a guy named Mitch. Did Audra have an affair with him?

Mitch, the mystery man, on The Young and the Restless

Kyle asked Sienna for dirt on Audra on The Young and the Restless | Image: CBS
Kyle asked Sienna for dirt on Audra on The Young and the Restless | Image: CBS

The Young and the Restless writers are doing a great job keeping us in suspense about Mitch. He hasn't even made an appearance yet, and we're already wondering whether he was involved in Noah's (Lucas Adams) car crash and the secret Holden (Nathan Owens) and Audra (Zuleyka Silver) are keeping.

Sienna (Tamara Braun) gave off the vibe that her marriage to Mitch may not be in the best shape, in the scene when she left him a frustrated voicemail, telling him he was supposed to be home two days ago. Why would a loving husband stay away from his wife for two days and not call her to tell her he isn't coming home?

That makes us wonder whether he's seeing another woman. And who knows? Maybe this isn't the first time he's been unfaithful. When Kyle (Michael Mealor) asked Sienna about Audra, Sienna had no interest in discussing her. Perhaps Kyle's questioning hit a nerve because Mitch once had an affair with Audra?

Did Audra cheat on Holden with Mitch?

Audra and Holden were once involved on The Young and the Restless | Image: YouTube
Audra and Holden were once involved on The Young and the Restless | Image: YouTube

We know Audra and Holden were romantically involved when they lived in L.A. Is Mitch the reason (or one of the reasons) why they broke up? Did Audra cheat on Holden with him?

When Holden first moved to Genoa City and Audra ran into him, we got the sense that he was still carrying a torch for her. He didn't want the break-up, it seemed. She was the one who ended their relationship.

Audra once described Holden as a man who liked to live on the edge when they were together, and that was the reason why she left him. But what if there was more to the story, and that something more was Mitch?

Were Holden and Sienna scorned by their partners?

Sienna and Holden had a mysterious argument on The Young and the Restless | Image: CBS
Sienna and Holden had a mysterious argument on The Young and the Restless | Image: CBS

When we saw Sienna and Holden in the middle of an intense conversation on The Young and the Restless, we assumed it had to do with Noah's car crash or the secret involving Holden and Audra. But what if they were simply discussing a mere case of infidelity? Maybe they were playing the blame game, and Sienna snapped, "If you had kept Audra satisfied, she never would have come sniffing around my husband!" And Holden snapped back, "If you knew how to keep Mitch happy, he never would have come between me and Audra!"

When we first met Sienna in her club, she told Claire and Holden that Audra is a "trouble-maker," but she didn't go into any details about it, which gives us yet another mystery to ponder. What exactly did Sienna mean by that? Will Audra be the next person to fly to L.A. and speak to Sienna in person? If she is, then will Mitch be the hot topic of their conversation?

Catch all-new episodes of The Young and the Restless weekdays on CBS and Paramount Plus.