In Blue Lock, fans often debate who should be Isagi Yoichi's true rival. While many lean toward Nagi Seishiro because of his talent and screen time, the reality is that Nagi could never truly be Isagi's final rival. The very foundation of their personalities and playstyles makes them incompatible as long-term rivals. And while their bond is deep, rivalry in Blue Lock is about more than skill. It’s about ambition, mindset, and evolution.
Nagi Seishiro entered Blue Lock as a natural genius. He didn’t even care much about soccer until Reo Mikage dragged him into it. His raw ability is what makes him special. He doesn’t need to think hard. He sees the ball and moves in a way no one expects.

In contrast, Isagi had no natural edge. In Blue Lock, Isagi grew through effort, planning, and reading the field. Every step he takes is earned. This major contrast is exactly why Nagi lacks the ambition or hunger to match Isagi’s drive.
In the show, Isagi is defined by growth. His greatest strength is his mind. He breaks down the field, adapts, and evolves in real time. He doesn’t just play; he controls the game. Nagi doesn’t do this. He thrives on instinct and doesn’t think deeply about the game unless pushed.

Even when Nagi "awakened" during the Z vs. V match, it took a direct challenge to light his fire. It was not until the idea of losing hit him that he switched on. But the problem is that this fire often goes out. Nagi doesn’t chase greatness the way Isagi does. That lack of consistency holds him back from being a serious rival to Isagi.
Some fans believe in the theory that Nagi and Isagi are destined to be final rivals. The theory is built on some interesting points: they were the first and last to enter Blue Lock, they wore the same jersey number, and they mirror each other’s movements. But being inverses doesn’t automatically make them equal.
In Blue Lock, rivalry is built on pushing each other to evolve constantly. While Isagi brings out the best in others, Nagi can’t even bring out the best in himself unless someone else forces him to.
Nagi breaks others down just by existing. His genius is so far above others that it can crush their confidence. Isagi, on the other hand, lifts people up and uses their growth to climb even higher. That’s a massive gap in their purpose and approach. A true rival matches you and makes you sharper. Nagi doesn’t do that consistently.

Even if Nagi has a comeback and fully awakens, his nature is static compared to Isagi’s constant motion. Blue Lock is a story of evolution, and Isagi is the embodiment of it. He’s always learning, adapting, and changing the flow of the game. Nagi, unless the story forces him to change, is not built for that level of continuous growth. And if a character can’t keep evolving, he can’t be Isagi’s final rival.
Isagi’s other rivals in Blue Lock
When you look at Isagi's actual rivals in Blue Lock (Barou, Rin, and Kaiser), they all challenge him in different ways. Barou brings ego and dominance, Rin brings balance and calmness, and Kaiser brings a level of skill that forces Isagi to rethink his game.
Each of them pushes Isagi into new territory. Nagi, on the other hand, mostly exists within his own bubble. He doesn’t clash with Isagi in a way that truly forces change. And Isagi doesn’t react to Nagi the same way he does to someone like Barou.

There’s also a key storytelling point in the anime. Every time Isagi surpasses a rival, he earns a new title. He beat Rin and became Blue Lock’s Ace. He overcame Barou, who was known as "The King," and took on the title "The Demon King."
But when it comes to Nagi, Isagi hasn’t surpassed him in name or reputation. Nagi is still the "Lazy Genius," while Isagi remains the planner, the thinker. If they were true equals, Blue Lock would have shown a clash of egos between them that leaves a mark. That hasn’t happened.
Conclusion
Fans should recognize that while Nagi is important, he works better as a past teammate than a final rival. His presence helped Isagi early on, but the road to being the best striker in the world doesn’t run through Nagi.

It runs through players who challenge Isagi in ambition, not just talent. In the end, Blue Lock is not about natural gifts. It’s about who wants it more. And Nagi, for all his skill, has never wanted it more than Isagi.