Here's why I believe fans are upset over Canaan James Hill and Kolbi Jordan's elimination from American Idol Season 23

American Idol Season 23
American Idol Season 23's Canaan James Hill and Kolbi Jordan | Image Source: Instagram/ @canaansangz @kolbijordan

Disclaimer: This American Idol article is based on the writer's opinion. Readers' discretion is advised.


American Idol Season 23's latest episode was released on May 4, 2025. While the Top 8 artists were revealed, the competition show also eliminated two skilled and fan-favorite artists. The most recent elimination from the ABC show was Canaan James Hill and Kolbi Jordan. As the two were sent home, fans seem to be upset over their elimination from the reality show.

As the fans know, elimination is part of the show, and as the show advances to the finale, it will get even harder. It is because all the contestants who are currently in the Top 8 have extraordinary skills and voices. Hence, no matter who gets sent home, it is going to affect many fans from across the globe.

Viewers have invested in the artists' journey, and when it ends, it is hard for everyone to move forward with the competition.


American Idol Season 23: The competition lost its two gems - Canaan James Hill and Kolbi Jordan

With each elimination, fans are overwhelmed as they do not want their favorite artists to leave the singing competition. However, eliminations are a part of the competition and a way to find those who truly have an one-of-a-kind voice and talent. Even though fans sometimes can not face their favorite artists leaving the show.

It is not only limited to the contestants; sometimes, when the judges are well-liked and have been an essential part of the show, their departure also affects the fans. Since Katy Perry left the ABC show, fans have enjoyed her replacement, Carrie Underwood, for her charming nature and calm personality.

However, many fans still feel Katy Perry's absence and share their sentiments via comments on social media platforms.

A fan wrote on X and mentioned Katy Perry and Carrie Underwood as the judges on the show:

"So she quit #AmericanIdol so she could train for Space? This is not acceptable. Carrie is great, but Katy has the rizz.."

Katy's quirky personality and bubbly nature, mixed with how she connects with the singers from their audition itself, were appreciated by fans.

American Idol Season 23's latest episode revealed the Top 8 participants, and with the elimination announcement, broke many fans' hearts. Everyone is aware that eliminations are part of the game, but when the competition is toward its finale, it is quite intense. Each of the contestants has their unique singing styles and stage presence.

Witnessing talented artists such as Canaan James Hill and Kolbi Jordan being eliminated, many fans shared their sentiments. Referring to their elimination, a fan wrote on X:

"Wow! Once again the American Idol audience had a week where they let the best go! Canaan and Kolbi are two of the strongest performers on the show! America got it wrong! #AmericanIdol."

American Idol Season 23 is one of the renowned singing reality shows and is followed by huge numbers of fans.


Fans can stream the upcoming American Idol Season 23 episode on May 5, 2025. Latest episodes are available on Hulu from the day after their release.

Edited by Gira Rathod