Nobody Wants This Season 2 tells us a lot about Noah, but here’s what you missed

Kristen Bell as Joanne and Adam Brody as Noah in Nobody Wants This (Image via Netflix)
Kristen Bell as Joanne and Adam Brody as Noah in Nobody Wants This (Image via Netflix)

Nobody Wants This Season 2 actually reveals a lot about Noah and a few more characters that were probably a bit on the sidelines in Season 1. We see more of Sasha, Esther, and Morgan. We also see more of Joanne and Morgan’s parents. This makes the season feel fuller and a lot more rounded than the last one. The story also gets deeper into themes like identity, faith, and belief. It makes us look closer at everyone we thought we already knew. Sometimes it even feels like we have to pause and re-evaluate each character of Nobody Wants This Season 2 because so many moments catch you off guard.

If we take Noah’s case, for instance, the lead character seems different this time. In Season 1, we were under the impression that he was this kind of gentle, loyal, special man who was that way only with Joanne. But in Season 2, we learn something that changes that image almost completely and makes us question him for a while. Still, the writing somehow keeps him grounded. He remains the Noah we know, yet there’s something new that makes us look at him differently. Before we jump to conclusions, though, it helps to understand where this change comes from.


Nobody Wants This: The psychology behind Noah’s love

In Nobody Wants This Season 2, Noah finds himself a little lost after leaving Temple Chai. Joanne and Morgan are recording their podcast one day, and Noah jumps in to answer a listener’s question about relationships. His response sounds sincere. But it doesn’t end there. A few days later, another listener calls Joanne and says she recognized Noah’s voice. She tells her that she used to date him. Her story paints him as one of those sweet but confusing men. They are romantic to the point of perfection, the kind who makes you feel special and then says it didn’t mean anything. That phone call plants a doubt in Joanne’s mind.

That doubt grows on Valentine’s Day in Nobody Wants This Season 2. Noah surprises Joanne with a necklace. But she realizes she’s seen a similar one before on Rebecca. The idea that every romantic gesture he’s done for her, he has also done for others, suddenly makes her feel ordinary. She can’t stop thinking about how the relationship seems stuck. They’re not talking about marriage anymore, and her conversion to Judaism still stands between them. When she confronts Noah, he doesn’t deny any of it. He insists that he’s just being a 'good boyfriend', that this is what dating looks like. Being thoughtful, supportive, and romantic. But it confuses her.

This brings us to Noah’s psychology. He’s the kind of man for whom romance means doing the right things like giving gifts, remembering dates, and being kind. It’s not fake; it’s who he is. But it also shows that he views relationships through patterns. He loves through repetition. His gestures come from habit and intention rather than instinct. Psychologically, that comes from a need for validation. He feels secure when he’s being the “good boyfriend”. He likes being the man who gets love right. It’s not that he doesn’t love Joanne. He just doesn’t know how to love any differently.

Nobody Wants This, however, knows how to satisfy its viewers. In the end, he runs back to Joanne and tells her that it doesn’t matter whether she converts or not. For the first time, Noah chooses emotion over ritual. And it’s in this moment that we realize he’s finally feeling it freely.


Stay tuned to Soap Central for more updates and detailed coverage.

Edited by Parishmita Baruah