Emily walks into her home to see Hal fastening a necklace around Barbara's neck. Instead of reacting angrily, Emily lovingly tells Hal that she has come back home where she belong. Barbara snarls in the background. Hal leaves to go talk to Daniel at Susan's house, and to pick up Emily's things from there. Emily takes the opportunity to lay down some rules for Barbara. Barbara is to dress herself, and Emily tells her, "You don't cook, you don't bake, and you don't show your face unless you are invited!" Then she dumps Barbara's pie into the trash. Barbara speaks politely to Emily, but evil thoughts echo inside her head. Hal returns and shares a tender reunion with Emily, as Barbara spies from the stairway.
Sierra finds Craig in the park and tells him that from now on she will take care of Lucy. Craig insists that Lucy's unhappiness was caused by Dusty, not him, but Sierra again tells Craig to stay away from Lucy - for good.
At Aaron's hospital bedside, Alison and Lucy discover that Aaron has no medical insurance. Upon hearing that, Lucy leaves abruptly.
At the police station, John Dixon visits Dusty and Dusty asks John to arrange for Dusty to pay Aaron's hospital bills. Lucy arrives just in time to hear them, and she asks Dusty how he could possibly pay such a large bill. She is interrupted by Tom Hughes, who tells Dusty that he is facing charges of conspiracy, fraud, illegal gaming, and aggravated battery (or manslaughter if Aaron doesn't survive). Tom tells Dusty that he is facing a 10-15 year jail sentence, at best. However, the district attorney is willing to drop all the charges against Dusty if he will testify against Dominic Ramsey. Dusty refuses, saying that he would be killed if he were to roll over on Dominic. As they escort Dusty from the room, he sees Lucy sorrowfully hugging Rafael Ortega. The sight of Lucy comforting Rafael makes Dusty send for Tom, ready to make a deal, on one condition. Dusty insists that he will testify only if all the charges against Rafael are dropped. Tom tells Rafael that he is free to go, thanks to Dusty.
Holden enters Aaron's hospital room, and he and Lucy see Aaron open his eyes, but he stares vacantly. Ben comes in to examine Aaron and finds that Aaron is not responsive. He orders a CT scan, "stat." While Aaron goes through tests, John Dixon anxiously reviews Aaron's chart and studies Ben's performance during Aaron's operation. Ben tells Holden, Alison, and John Dixon that Aaron has regressed - he is unresponsive to pain and his pupils are unequal. After he sees the test results, Ben frowns and mutters, "Damn!" He goes back to Holden and Alison and tells them that Aaron has developed a subdural hematoma and must go back into surgery right away. Holden takes John aside and tells him that he thinks that Ben is holding something back. John promises Holden to find out the truth. John meets Bob outside the hospital and tells him that he is afraid that Aaron's case might be a liability for the hospital. Lily does her best to comfort Holden.
Holden, Lily and Alison are frightened and distraught over the news of Aaron's second surgery. Bob gets word of this and off John's insistence that he investigate Ben, Bob begins to have serious concerns.
Meanwhile, Jessica tells Margo she's signed the divorce papers and how she accused Ben of abusing painkillers. Margo counsels her to keep fighting for her marriage, but Jessica says she owes it to Ben to give him what he wants. With divorce papers in hand, Jessica finds Ben at the hospital when John interrupts with the news that Ben is dismissed from Aaron's case and Jessica is twigged that something is up. Later, Jessica finds Ben at Java, gives him the papers and tries to solicit him to talk to her but he shuts down. Meanwhile, Bob tells Holden, Lily and Alison that Aaron is stabilized, but in all likelihood, there's been some brain damage.
Distraught Carly learns from Paul and Rosanna that they're engaged. She breaks down and tells them what happened with Jack, Julia and her abusive husband. Rosanna advises Carly to go to Jack, plead her case and make Jack understand it was a misunderstanding. Later, Carly goes looking for Jack but finds Julia instead. Carly launches in with an explanation, but Julia accuses her of playing the victim to get what she wants. She further rocks Carly by saying it doesn't matter if Jack gets his memories back or not because Jack loves her now. Carly says she's confident that once Jack remembers their love, he'll come back to her and both women walk away realizing they are both up against powerful adversaries.
Lucy asks Dusty if he took a deal to get Rafi off and though he downplays it, a slip by Tom lets Lucy know he did. Lucy is concerned for Dusty's safety, but he sends her away. Meanwhile, Craig learns that Sierra is staying in Oakdale for good. He goes off to bail Rafi out of jail, but finds at the station that not only has Dusty gotten Rafi released, he's getting released, too. Craig and Dusty face off while Dom is led out and utters a threat to both of them. Meanwhile, Lucy finds Sierra at home and confides she blew it with Dusty but Sierra says it may not be over between them.
Rosanna and Paul ask Will to be their best man and to come live with them after they're married. Will is thrilled and says yes to both offers.
Rosanna tells Carly she should play dirty in order to get her man back! Carly finally agrees and the sisters make a deal to formulate a plan with Emily at Rosanna's wedding to get Jack back in Carly's arms.
Meanwhile, Paul and Jordan bury the hatchet and Paul asks his brother to his wedding to represent the closest thing Rosanna has to Cabot. Later, Jennifer runs into Mike at the police station and they both learn that the other is going to Rosanna and Paul's wedding. Mike suggests they go together, but after some alone time in the interrogation room where they tear each other's clothes off, Jennifer declines, determined to keep their relationship professional. Later, Jordan runs into Jennifer and both learn each other is going to the wedding. Jordan asks Jennifer to go with him, but she lies, says she's already going with Mike and goes off to re-invite Mike to be her date.
Lucy tries to convince Holden that Rafi's not to blame for Aaron's accident and that Aaron will turn the corner and be okay. Holden goes off to pay Aaron's medical bills, but John tells him it's already been taken care of by Dusty. Later, when Dusty sneaks into Aaron's room, Lucy finds him there and tells him about Aaron's possible brain damage. Dusty emerges from Aaron's room and is confronted by Holden. Meanwhile, Alison and Curtis call Nancy over to Metro to help gather up some of Aaron's favorite things. Nancy and Alison head to the hospital where they encounter Dusty and Lucy. Alison goes into Aaron's room with the stuff and when she makes a bedside confession of love to him, he opens his eyes and starts to talk! Alison finds Holden and pulls him into Aaron's room to share the great news but Aaron senses something's wrong with him. Meanwhile, Lucy tells Dusty she may have been a little harsh over the boxing thing and doesn't think they should be apart.
Ben asks Curtis to keep the fact that he took the urine test for him a secret. Later, Ben runs into Jessica, who, fresh from a conversation with John, warns Ben that John's on a warpath and could possibly pin Aaron's condition on Ben.
A thrilled Rosanna comes upon Paul decorating the barn for their wedding and joins in. The topic of where they'll live after the wedding comes up and much to their surprise, Rosanna overrules Paul's choice for his penthouse and suggests Fairwinds. Rosanna and Paul hash it out and Rosanna says she wants to make Fairwinds their home. She doesn't want to run from memories of Cabot or the past, rather, she wants to embrace them and make new ones with Paul and Will. Paul agrees and when he tells Will, Will is inspired to stop running from the past. Will then decides he'll be the one to tell Barbara what he wants for his life. Meanwhile, Emily tries to surreptitiously get ready for the wedding and keep Barbara from realizing something is up, which only tweaks Barbara's curiosity. When Will goes to Hal's house to tell his father he wants to tell Barbara the truth, Barbara overhears that Paul is getting married tonight.
Dusty does his best to push Lucy away, but Lucy counters with a strong emotional pitch. Ultimately, Dusty says he can't be the man Lucy wants him to be and walks away, leaving Lucy devastated. Meanwhile, Alison and Holden are trying to keep a freaked Aaron calm about his numbness. He goes off for tests and all agree not to discuss the fight around him. Aaron comes back from his tests and is alone when an unknowing Rafael comes for a visit to apologize. When he inadvertently tells Aaron about the fixed fight and that he had brain surgery, Aaron reacts badly and demands to know what's wrong with him! Alison comes back in and throws Rafi out, telling him he's done enough damage. Later, Alison and Holden learn that Aaron's left side is paralyzed. A distraught and guilty Rafael encounters an equally distraught and devastated Lucy in the courtyard and the two console each other in an embrace. Dusty, feeling bad about how he left Lucy walks in on this scene but does the better thing and leaves unnoticed.
Jack and Julia come to Milltown to ask Carly to sign divorce papers that Jack has drawn up. Unable to deal with this, Carly says she'll look at the papers after Rosanna's wedding but, Jack gets angry, thinking Carly has no intention of signing. Things go badly and Carly throws them both out, only later to discover that Jack shoved the papers under the door. Later, Jack tells Julia they should act like the couple they are and go to Thanksgiving at Emma's together, hoping Carly will realize it's pointless to fight the divorce.
Mike and Jennifer decide to attend the wedding together if, and only if, Jennifer settles her unfinished business with Jordan.
Barbara confronts Will and Hal about Paul's wedding. Will insists on handling this himself and, since he's posted police guards outside, a reluctant Hal leaves Will with his mother. Will drops the bomb that not only is Paul marrying Rosanna tonight, but that Will is going to live with them at Fairwinds. Barbara is furious but feigns indifference in front of Will as he leaves for the wedding. Once Will leaves, Barbara lures the policeman inside for coffee, then goes upstairs to nap. Meanwhile, at the Snyder Barn, just as Paul is expressing his concern to Hal for leaving Will alone with Barbara, Will arrives. Will goes to his Aunt Kim to tell her about his conversation with Barbara and even though he says Barbara was fine with everything, Kim is concerned. Meanwhile, Barbara climbs out of her bedroom window and struggles to remove her electronic tracking anklet, vowing to get to the wedding.
A tearful, shell-shocked Carly stares at the divorce papers Jack left for her. Emily arrives, and as Carly starts to tell her what happened with Jack, Rosanna shows up to get into her wedding dress. Carly swears Emily to secrecy, vowing not to ruin Rosanna 's wedding day, but Rosanna picks up on Carly's sadness and the two friends work to comfort Carly. Meanwhile, Julia calms Jack's anger over Carly's refusal to sign the divorce papers and suggests they wait until after Thanksgiving. Jack asks again if Julia and JJ will join him at Emma's for dinner and when Julia is again reluctant, Jack asks her to go with him to the farm and ask Emma. Later on, Carly, Rosanna and Emily arrive at the farm and when Carly sees the barn decorated for the wedding, and it's so reminiscent of her wedding to Jack that it knocks the wind out of her. She rushes out and runs right into Jack and Julia. Jack sees the barn and has a similar reaction to Carly's, but downplays it when she calls him on it. Emma hustles Jack and Julia out of there but not before Carly realizes that the memories of her and Jack's love are in him somewhere. Rosanna and Emily help her try to figure out how to get him to remember until Emma announces it's time for the wedding to begin. As the wedding starts and Carly walks down the aisle, Jack, simultaneously at Java, gets down on one knee and proposes to a stunned Julia. A jubilant Julia accepts as a beautiful Rosanna starts down the aisle to Paul.