Following is a complete listing of each of the winners in the Outstanding Guest Performer category. This category was introduced in 2015 as a way to honor actors who offered memorable performances, but appeared only briefly on a soap. At its inception, Guest Performer nominees were not permitted to have appeared as their character in a previous calendar year. In 2019, Guest Performer nominees were permitted to have appeared in their role in previous calendar years, but in their nominated year they were permitted to appear only in certain number of episodes. That episode count was not made public.
• 2014-2015; Donna Mills (Madeline Reeves, General Hospital) [TIE]
• 2014-2015; Fred Willard (John Forrester, The Bold and the Beautiful) [TIE]
• 2014-2015; Ray Wise (Ian Ward, The Young and the Restless) [TIE]
• 2015-2016; Obba Babatundé (Julius Avant, The Bold and the Beautiful)
• 2016-2017; Jim O'Heir (Matt Cannistra, The Bold and the Beautiful)
• 2017-2018; Vernee Watson (Stella Henry, General Hospital)
• 2018-2019; Patricia Berthune (Mary Pat Ingles, General Hospital)
• 2019-2020; Eva LaRue (Celeste Rosales, The Young and the Restless)
• 2020-2021; Cady McClain (Jennifer Horton-Deveraux, Days of our Lives)
• 2021-2022; Ted King (Jack Finnegan, The Bold and the Beautiful)
• 2022-2023; Alley Mills (Heather Webber, General Hospital)
The Bold and the Beautiful; 4 wins
General Hospital; 4 wins
The Young and the Restless; 2 wins
Days of our Lives; 1 win
